Tables index

From

Measuring Maturity and Ranking Barriers to Implementing Benchmarking of Construction Project Quality Management in Cagayan de Oro City

Mary Kaye Paquibot, Jonathan B. Calibara

American Journal of Civil Engineering and Architecture. 2026, 14(3), 69-111 doi:10.12691/ajcea-14-3-2
  • Table 1. Various issues encountered in a construction project
  • Table 2. Nine (9) PMBOK Knowledge Area
  • Table 3. Project Management Maturity Indicators (Koenig, 2015)
  • Table 4. Interpretation of Maturity Levels (Karim et al., 2022)
  • Table 5. Project Management Maturity Model Survey Scale
  • Table 6. Ten (10) Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)
  • Table 7. The number of experts and acceptable S-CVI Values (Yusoff, 2019)
  • Table 8. Interpretation of Content Validity Index (CVI)
  • Table 9. Interpretation of KMO Values
  • Table 10. Interpretation of Bartlett’s Test of Sphericity
  • Table 11. Interpretation of Cronbach’s Alpha
  • Table 12. Stakeholders’ Perception Research Indicators
  • Table 13. Stakeholders’ Perception Research Indicators
  • Table 14. Interpretation of Relative Impact Index (RII) Values
  • Table 15. Key Barriers Research Variables
  • Table 16. Pairwise Comparison Saaty Scale (Odd Values)
  • Table 17. Triangular Fuzzy Numbers (TFNs)
  • Table 18. Random index values (Saaty, 1980)
  • Table 19. Summary of Scale Level Content Validation Result
  • Table 20. Reliability Statistics of the Instrument
  • Table 21. Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin (KMO) and Bartlett’s Test Results
  • Table 22. Assessment of Project Management Maturity Survey Data
  • Table 23. Stakeholders’ Perception Rating
  • Table 24. Transformed Aggregated Fuzzy Comparison Matrix of the Barriers Dimensions
  • Table 25. Transformed Aggregated Fuzzy Comparison Matrix of Barriers under Quality
  • Table 26. Transformed Aggregated Fuzzy Comparison Matrix of Barriers under Human Capital
  • Table 27. Transformed Aggregated Fuzzy Comparison Matrix of Barriers under Stakeholder Satisfaction
  • Table 28. Transformed Aggregated Fuzzy Comparison Matrix of Barriers under Technology
  • Table 29. Transformed Aggregated Fuzzy Comparison Matrix of Barriers under Economic-Political
  • Table 30. Aggregated Crisp Comparison Matrix of the Barriers Dimensions
  • Table 31. Aggregated Crisp Comparison Matrix of Barriers under Quality
  • Table 32. Aggregated Crisp Comparison Matrix of Barriers under Human Capital
  • Table 33. Aggregated Crisp Comparison Matrix of Barriers under Technology
  • Table 34. Aggregated Crisp Comparison Matrix of Barriers under Stakeholder Satisfaction
  • Table 35. Aggregated Crisp Comparison Matrix of Barriers under Economic-Political
  • Table 36. Resulting Matrix of the Barriers Dimensions
  • Table 37. Resulting Matrix of the Barriers under Quality
  • Table 38. Resulting Matrix of the Barriers under Human Capital
  • Table 39. Resulting Matrix of the Barriers under Technology
  • Table 40. Resulting Matrix of the Barriers under Stakeholder Satisfaction
  • Table 41. Resulting Matrix of the Barriers under Economic-Political
  • Table 42. Resulting Aggregated Crisp Weights of the Barriers Dimensions
  • Table 43. Resulting Aggregated Crisp Weights of Barriers under Quality
  • Table 44. Resulting Aggregated Crisp Weights of Barriers under Human Capital
  • Table 45. Resulting Aggregated Crisp Weights of Barriers under Technology
  • Table 46. Resulting Aggregated Crisp Weights of Barriers under Stakeholder Satisfaction
  • Table 47. Resulting Aggregated Crisp Weights of Barriers under Economic-Political
  • Table 48. Classification of Maturity Result (Karim et al., 2022)
  • Table 49. Summary of Maturity and Rankings (Cooke-Davies & Arzymanow, 2003; Crawford, 2015)
  • Table 50. Maturity Indicators Summary of Maturity Index
  • Table 51. Perceived benefits of benchmarking ranked by mean score
  • Table 52. Relative Importance Index (RII) Result and Ranking
  • Table 53. Perceived benefits of benchmarking ranked by mean score
  • Table 54. Transformed Aggregated Fuzzy Pairwise Comparison Matrix for Barriers under Quality
  • Table 55. Transformed Aggregated Fuzzy Pairwise Comparison Matrix for Barriers under Human Capital
  • Table 56. Transformed Aggregated Fuzzy Pairwise Comparison Matrix for Barriers under Technology
  • Table 57. Transformed Aggregated Fuzzy Pairwise Comparison Matrix for Barriers under Stakeholder Satisfaction
  • Table 58. Transformed Aggregated Fuzzy Pairwise Comparison Matrix for Barriers under Economic-Political
  • Table 59. Transformed Aggregated Fuzzy Pairwise Comparison Matrix for Barriers under Economic-Political
  • Table 60. Weights and Rankings of Key Barriers