Isolation and Antimicrobial Susceptability of Listeria Monocytogenes from Raw Milk and Milk P...

U. B. USMAN, J. K. P. KWAGA, J. KABIR, O. S. OLONITOLA

Journal of Applied & Environmental Microbiology

Isolation and Antimicrobial Susceptability of Listeria Monocytogenes from Raw Milk and Milk Products in Northern Kaduna State, Nigeria

U. B. USMAN1,, J. K. P. KWAGA2, J. KABIR2, O. S. OLONITOLA3

1Division of Veterinary Services, Ministry of Animal Health and Fisheries Development, Sokoto, Nigeria

2Department of Veterinary Public Health and Preventive Medicine, Faculty of veterinary medicine, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria

3Department of Microbiology, faculty of Science, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria

Abstract

Listeria (L.) monocytogenes is an ‘emerging food borne pathogen’ that poses threat to global food safety. Its occurrence in milk and milk products constitute a negative impact to the dairy industry. Despite its veterinary public health significance, only few studies are available on the prevalence and characteristics of the organism from milk and milk products in Nigeria. The main objectives of this study were to isolate, identify and determine the antibiotic susceptibility patterns of the Listeria monocytogenes isolated from raw milk and milk product in Kaduna state Nigeria. A total of 550 samples of raw milk and milk products (fermented milk “Kindrimo” and milk butter “Manshanu”) were collected during a cross-sectional study. Of these 550 samples, 193 (35.10%) samples were positive for Listeria species- like growth when plated on chromogenic Listeria agar, 91 (47.15%) from raw milk, 65 (33.67%) from ‘Manshanu’ and 37 (19.15%) ‘Kindrimo’. A total of 36 (6.55%) were found to be L. monocytogenes based on conventional biochemical tests. However, when further subjected to MicrobactTM Listeria 12L detection Kit (Oxoid, MB1128A) only 3 (8.3%) of the 36 isolates were identified as L. monocytogenes, while the others were L. grayi 4 (11.1%), L. ivanovii 27 (75.0%) and L. seeligeri 2 (5.6%). The multiplex PCR assay identified 9 Listeria (L.) monocytogenes isolates harbouring the hly A gene. The susceptibility of 36 L. monocytogenes isolates to 10 antibiotics was evaluated using the disk diffusion method. Isolates from milk samples had an overall resistance of 64.09% to the antibiotics, followed by isolates from ‘Kindrimo’ (61.67%), and least resistance was observed in isolates from ‘Manshanu” (58.33%). Overall, L. monocytogenes isolates showed the highest frequency of resistance to ampicillin (100%), followed by penicillin (95%) and cloxacillin (90%). In conclusion, the isolation of L. monocytogenes and other Listeria species in this study calls for an improved hygienic practices in the milk and milk products production channels and for the enlightment of the Fulani herds men and women by agricultural extension workers. Also, the resistance pattern shown by the isolates is an indication that the use of antibiotics should be regulated to minimize the incidence of antibiotic resistance.

Cite this article:

  • U. B. USMAN, J. K. P. KWAGA, J. KABIR, O. S. OLONITOLA. Isolation and Antimicrobial Susceptability of Listeria Monocytogenes from Raw Milk and Milk Products in Northern Kaduna State, Nigeria. Journal of Applied & Environmental Microbiology. Vol. 4, No. 3, 2016, pp 46-54. http://pubs.sciepub.com/jaem/4/3/1
  • USMAN, U. B., et al. "Isolation and Antimicrobial Susceptability of Listeria Monocytogenes from Raw Milk and Milk Products in Northern Kaduna State, Nigeria." Journal of Applied & Environmental Microbiology 4.3 (2016): 46-54.
  • USMAN, U. B. , KWAGA, J. K. P. , KABIR, J. , & OLONITOLA, O. S. (2016). Isolation and Antimicrobial Susceptability of Listeria Monocytogenes from Raw Milk and Milk Products in Northern Kaduna State, Nigeria. Journal of Applied & Environmental Microbiology, 4(3), 46-54.
  • USMAN, U. B., J. K. P. KWAGA, J. KABIR, and O. S. OLONITOLA. "Isolation and Antimicrobial Susceptability of Listeria Monocytogenes from Raw Milk and Milk Products in Northern Kaduna State, Nigeria." Journal of Applied & Environmental Microbiology 4, no. 3 (2016): 46-54.

Import into BibTeX Import into EndNote Import into RefMan Import into RefWorks

At a glance: Figures

1. Introduction

Milk is composed of water, carbohydrate, fats, proteins, minerals and vitamins. Milk plays a leading role in improving the nutritional status of human populace, most especially in areas of high prevalence of protein deficiency [1]. However, it often serves as a medium for milk borne diseases [2]. As a practice and source of food, pastoralist usually process fresh milk into various traditional products such as ‘Nono’ (Sour milk), ‘Kindrimo’ (sour yoghourt), ‘Manshanu’ (local butter) and ‘Cuku’ (Fulani cheese) [3]. Dairy products such as milk, cheese, ice cream and butter have all been implicated as a cause of milk borne diseases [4]. Traditionally fermented milk products are commonly consumed in Asia, Africa, the Middle East and Northern and Eastern Europe. However, preparation and composition of milk product varies from one region to the other [5].

The genus Listeria consists of 10 species; L. monocytogenes, L. innocua, L. seeligeri, L. welshimeri, L. ivanovii, L. grayi, L. marthii [6], L. rocourtiae [7], L. fleischmannii [8], and L. weihenstephanensis [9]. Recently, five new Listeria species (L. floridensis sp. Nov., L. aquatic sp. Nov., L. cornellensis sp. Nov., L. riparia sp. Nov., and L. grandensis sp were identified from agricultural & natural environments in the United States [10]. No haemolytic activity or PI-PLC activity, suggesting these species lack the genes (hly A and plc A) associated with virulence in L. monocytogenes and L. ivanovii. The absence of virulence genes found in the prf A cluster [11] or LIPI-2 [12] from the draft genome, further support that none of the new species described here are pathogenic.

L. ivanovii and L. monocytogenes are pathogenic for mice and other animals. However only L. monocytogenes is commonly associated with human listeriosis. Listeriosis associated infection by L. ivanovii, and even L. seeligeri is extremely rare in humans. The major mode of transmission of L. monocytogenes is via the ingestion of contaminated food [13]. Human listeriosis is a sporadic disease, which is associated with consumption of contaminated milk, soft cheese, under-cooked meat, and unwashed raw vegetables and cabbage [14, 15, 16]. In human, the illness may range from mild flu-like sickness to severe manifestations (encephalitis, meningitis, septicaemia, abortion, premature birth, stillbirth, and abscesses).

Listeriosis is ranked third of the major pathogens transmitted by food [17]. Studies on the microbiological characteristics of several fermented milk products have been carried out in many countries, including Nigeria [18]. Thus, outbreaks are reported on a regular basis, even though most cases occur unexpectedly [19]. High risk groups include the old, young, pregnant women and immunocompromised individuals [20]. The disease poses a very serious public health problem, due its high case fatality rate of 30%, which might rise to 75% in high risk individuals [21]. It has a high hospitalization rate compared to other food borne infections [22]. With the exception of cephalosporins, fosfomycin, and early quinolones to which innate resistance has been reported [23, 24]), L. monocytogenes is generally considered sensitive to most clinically relevant antibiotics [23, 25]. Even though antibiotics are the drug of choice, multidrug resistant strains have been identified [26]. At present, there is limited data on the prevalence and antimicrobial susceptibility patterns of L. monocytogenes in milk and milk-product in Nigeria. Hence the present study was undertaken.

2. Materials and Methods

The study was designed as a cross-sectional study and sampling was done for seven months between the periods of August, 2012 to February, 2013. Samples of raw milk 173(31.5%) and milk products 377(68.5%) making a total of 550, were collected using 50 ml sterile plastic containers (for raw milk and fermented milk ‘Kindrimo’) and 50 ml polythene bags (for milk butter ‘Manshanu’) respectively, from four Local government areas (Sabon gari, Lere, Makarfi and Zaria). They were labelled appropriately and transported on ice to the Bacterial Zoonosis Laboratory of the Department of Veterinary Public Health and Preventive Medicine, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria where the conventional biochemical analysis and antibiotic susceptibility testing was undertaken. The reference strain, Listeria monocytogenes ATCC 19155 used as positive control in this study was kindly provided by Prof. Son Radu of the Centre of Excellence for Food Safety Research, Faculty of Food Science and Technology, University Putra Malaysia, where the molecular studies aspect was carried out.

2.1. Isolation and Identification of L. monocytogenes

The isolation of Listeria monocytogenes was adapted according to the procedure of Roberts et al. [27]. Ten ml of the incubated homogenate were added to 90 ml Listeria enrichment broth (Oxoid, CM 0862), which contains selective Listeria enrichment supplements (Oxoid, SR 0141E) and incubated at 30oC for 48hrs. A loop full of the 48hrs broth was cultured onto Chromogenic Listeria agar (Oxoid, CM 1080) plates, which contains brilliance TM Listeria differential supplement (Oxoid, SR 0228E) and brilliance TM Listeria selective supplement (Oxoid, SR 00227) and the plates was incubated at 37°C for 24-48hrs. Presumptive colonies of Listeria monocytogenes having a greenish-blue coloration were picked and streaked on Nutrient agar (Oxoid, CM 0003) slants and incubated at 37°C for 24hrs, before storage at 4-5°C. The suspected isolates were further subjected to conventional biochemical test [Gram staining, oxidase, catalase, β-hemolysis, bile asculine and carbohydrate fermentation test (xylose, Mannitol, Rhamnose, Maltose, Inositol and Sucrose)] as described by [28]. Isolates found to ferment mannitol and xylose, and positive to rhamnose were considered L. monocytogenes. Further characterization using Microbact TM 12L Listeria identification kit (Oxoid, MB 1128) was carried out according to the manufactures instructions.

2.2. DNA Extraction and Multiplex Polymerase Chain Reaction

Bacterial genomic DNA was extracted from the L. monocytogenes isolates using the Quick-g DNATM miniprep kit, (Zymo Research, S.A.) following the manufacturer’s instructions. Multiplex PCR was used to detect L. monocytogenes isolates harbouring hly A gene. The primer pairs designated as LM1 & LM2 (LM1 5ʹ–CCT AAG ACG CCA ATC GAA-3ʹand LM2 –5'-AAG CGC TTG CAA CTG CTC-3ʹ) were used for the detection of L. monocytogenes harbouring hly A gene. On the other hand, primer pairs designated as U1 and LI1 (LI1 5'–CTC CAT AAA GGT GAC CCT-3ʹ and U1 5'– CAG CMG CCG CGG TAATWC-3ʹ), were used to amplify a 938bp region in the 16S rRNA gene for the detection of Listeria genus [29]. The primers were synthesized by Invitrogen USA, and were 18-20bp in length. L. monocytogenes ATCC 19155 was used as a positive control. The PCR amplification was carried out in a 25µL reaction mixture, that consisted of 5µL of 5× PCR buffer, dNTPs (0.5µL), MgCl2 (2µL), Taq DNA polymerase (0.5µL), 0.5µL of each 20pM primer [LM1, LM2, U1 & LI1], 13µL of distilled water and 2µL of DNA template. A 96- well thermal cycler (Applied biosystems, Foster city, CA) was used for the amplification. PCR amplification was carried out in a programmed thermocyler with following conditions; hot start PCR at 95°C for 3mins; followed by 35cycles each, of 30 sec denaturation at 94°C, 15 sec annealing at 53°C, 90 sec extension for 72°C, and final extension at 72°C for 7 mins.

Five (5) micro litres of the PCR products was electrophoresed in 1.0% Agarose gel, stained with Ethidium bromide, at 100V for 45min and visualized under UV illuminator (SYNGENE, Biosystems UK, 2000). A 100bp DNA molecular ladder (Promega, Promega Corporation, USA) was included to determine the size of the amplified products.

2.3. Antibiotic Sensitivity

The disc diffusion method was used to determine the antibiotic susceptibility of the L. monocytogenes isolates on Mueller Hinton agar [30]. Three to five pure colonies of L. monocytogenes isolates were inoculated into 10 ml of brain heart infusion broth (Oxoid, CM 1135) and the test tube was diluted with normal saline to a turbidity equivalent to 0.5 McFarland standards (approximately 108 cfu/ml), and incubated at 37°C for 18-24hrs.The entire surface of a dried Mueller Hinton agar (Oxoid, CM0337) plate was swabbed with the 24hrs inoculum using a sterile cotton swab and allowed to dry for 10 minutes at room temperature under a biological hood. Standard antibiotic discs obtained from Oxoid (Hampshire, United Kingdom), Gentamicin (30µg), Ciprofloxacin (5µg), Ampicillin (10µg), Chloramphenicol (30µg), Streptomycin (10µg), Penicillin (10µg), Oxacillin (5µg), Sulfamethoxazole-Trimethoprim (25µg), Tetracycline (30µg) and Erythromycin (15µg) were applied to the Mueller Hinton agar plates using a disc dispenser (Oxoid, ST8090) and the plates were incubated at 37°C for 18 hrs. The zone of inhibition that were observed were measured to the nearest millimetre and used to determine the susceptibility of the isolates according to the Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute standard guidelines [31]. Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923 was used as a control strain [32]. Strains were evaluated as susceptible or resistant. Multiple antibiotic resistance (MAR) index for each resistance pattern was calculated by the formula given by [33]

2.4. Statistical Analysis

Data obtained was analyzed using the Statistical Package for Social Science (SPSS) version 20.0 (SPSS Inc, Chicago, USA) and the results presented in tables and charts. Frequency distribution and chi square test were calculated for the prevalence as well as antibiotic resistance of L. monocytogenes isolates to commonly used antibiotics. P value 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

3. Result

3.1. Sample Type Distribution

The sample type distribution showed that, of the total 193 (35.10%) samples positive for Listeria species when platted on chromogenic Listeria agar, 91(52.60%) were raw milk, 65(42.21%) ‘Manshanu’ and 37 (16.60%) ‘Kindrimo’. When the association between the isolation rate for Listeria species and the sample type was tested, there was significant association between the two (P<0.0001) (Table 1).

Table 1. Distribution of presumptive Listeria species based on sample type

3.2. Distribution of Listeria monocytogenes Based on Sample Type

The distribution of 36 L. monocytogenes isolates (Table 2) based on sample type showed that 14(8.09%) of the L. monocytogenes were from raw milk, 14(9.09%) ‘Manshanu’ and 8(3.59%) ‘Kindrimo’, giving an overall prevalence of 36 (6.55%) for L.monocytogenes in this study. When the association between the isolation rate for L. monocytogenes and the sample type was tested, there was no significant association between the two (P<0.064) (Table 3).

Table 2. Listeria monocytogenes isolates identified using conventional biochemical test

Table 3. Distribution of L. monocytogenes based on sample type

3.3. Distribution of Listeria monocytogenes Based on Local Government Areas

The distribution of L. monocytogenes based on the local government areas (Sabon gari, Zaria, Makarfi and Lere), showed that Sabon gari had the highest isolation rate of 14(10.9%), followed by Zaria 13(7.9%), Makarfi 5(3.4%) and Lere 4(3.7%). When the association between the isolation rate for L. monocytogenes and the local government areas was tested, a statistically significant association was observed (P<0.0413) (Table 4).

Table 4. Distribution of Listeria monocytogenes in milk and milk products based on Local Government Areas

3.4. Detection of hly A Harbouring Listeria monocytogenes Isolates

The PCR results for the detection of hly A gene among the 36 L. monocytogenes isolates showed that only 9(25.0%) (ZKMM84, SGHR30, SGSK1, ZKJR56, ZKJR39, ZKMR75, SGMM87, SGHR15 & LMFR162) L. monocytogenes isolates harboured the hly A gene (Figure 1).

Figure 1. Agarose gel electrophoresis of the PCR products obtained after amplification of the 16S rRNA gene (938bp) and listeriolysin O encoding gene (hly A) (702bp) from different Listeria monocytogenes isolates from raw milk and milk products. Lane M; 100bp ladder, Lane P: Positive control (Listeria monocytogenes ATCC 19155), Lane N: Negative control, Lane 1: Listeria monocytogenes (LM) isolate ZKMM84; Lane 2: LM SGHR 30; Lane 3: LM SGSK1; Lane 4: LM ZKJR56; Lane 5: LM SGHR39; Lane 6: LM ZKMR75; Lane 7: LM SGMM87; Lane 8:LM SGHR15; Lane 9: LM LMFR162
Figure 2. Percentage resistance of Listeria monocytogenes to a panel of 10 antibiotic agents
3.5. Antibiotic Resistance Pattern

All the isolates tested were resistant to ampicillin (100%), they also resisted penicillin (95%), followed by cloxacillin (90%) and resistance to streptomycin was the least (17.5%), followed by resistance to chloramphenicol with (25%) (Figure 2).

Table 5. Antibacterial susceptibility of 36 Listeria monocytogenes isolates from milk and milk products

The antimicrobial resistance profiles of the isolates showed that all the isolates were resistant to at least one or more antimicrobial agents and majority (75%) of the isolates the isolates were resistant to more than 3 antimicrobial agents. The susceptibility testing of the 36 L. monocytogenes isolates gave 30 different antimicrobial resistance patterns (Appendix 1).

3.6. Multiple Antibiotic Resistance

The antibiotic resistances profile of the L. monocytogenes isolates are shown in (Table 6). The results revealed that all the isolates were resistant to at least one antibiotic. However, only 3 (8.3%) of the isolates were resistant to less than 3 antibiotics, while 33 (77.5 %) of the isolates were resistant to 3 or more antibiotics (Table 6).

Table 6. Multiple drug resistance of Listeria monocytogenes isolates

3.7. Multiple Antibiotic Resistance Index

The results of this study revealed that majority of the isolates 32(88.9%) had MAR index greater than 0.2, with 14(38.8%) of the isolates having considerably higher MAR index (0.6-0.9). Only 4(11.11%) of the L. monocytogenes isolates had MAR index less than 0.2 (Table 7 & Appendix 2). Hence, it was not surprising to find 53.3% of the isolates with high MAR index originated from raw milk samples.

Table 7. Multiple antibiotics resistance (MAR) index of Listeria monocytogenes isolates

4. Discussion

Among the 550 samples tested, 193(35.1%) were presumptively positive for Listeria spp. based on their colour and colonial morphology when plated on Chromogenic Listeria agar (Table 1). In a similar study, [34] obtained a prevalence rate of 83 (18.6%) for Listeria species from 446 raw milk samples in Tehran, Iran. Based on their ability to ferment sugars (Rhamnose, Xylose and Mannitol) and other conventional biochemical tests, 36(6.55%) of the 196 (35.1%) presumptive Listeria species were identified as L. monocytogenes (Table 2). The prevalence of 6.55% obtained for L. monocytogenes in this study is comparable to other surveys conducted in other countries on raw milk and milk products. Reference [35] reported a prevalence of 5.7% from bovine raw milk produced in the North Eastern Algeria, whereas in China, the prevalence of L. monocytogenes was found to be very low (0.23 – 1.2%) [36]. A lower prevalence (16.6%) for Listeria species was obtained for ‘kindrimo’ in this study, as compared to (52.6%) raw milk and (42.2%) ‘Manshanu’ (Table 1). This lower prevalence obtained could be due to the conversion of lactose during fermentation by the lactic acid bacteria present in the ‘ Kindrimo’ to lactic acid, which lowers the pH of the kindrimo and hence the inhibition of Listeria species. Reference [37] reported that fermented milk products are rich in lactic acid bacteria; they also reported that bacteriocin produced by lactic acid bacteria has been found to reduce counts of Listeria species in cheese and Yoghurt. The implication of this finding is that raw milk and milk products which are ready to consume products, are mostly consumed without pasteurization, as such could serve as sources of infection to the population especially the high risk individuals.

The distribution of L. monocytogenes based on sample type followed the same pattern as the distribution of Listeria species, where a lower detection rate of 8(3.6%) for L. monocytogenes from ‘kindrimo’ as compared to 14(18.1%) for raw milk and 14(9.1%) for ‘Manshanu’; the only difference was that there was no statistically significant association (P=0.064) between the isolation rate of L. monocytogenes and the sample type (Table 2).

The prevalence of 6.6 % for L. monocytogenes obtained in this present study (Table 2) is lower than 48.33 % reported by [38] in goat milk, and 22.4 % by [39] in cattle milk in Sokoto. In other regions of the world, similar studies have reported prevalence rates of 0.57 % in Istanbul from foods [40], 5 % in India from bovine raw milk [41], 11.4 % in Iran in ready-to-eat foods [34].

Contamination of food by L. monocytogenes may occur at any point from farm to the table [42].The high nutritional value of milk and milk products make them suitable for pathogenic organisms including L. monocytogenes to thrive [43].

The low prevalence of L. monocytogenes obtained in Makarfi 5 (3.4%) and Lere 4 (3.7%) in this study could be attributed to the large number of samples of ‘Kindrimo’ sampled from these two local government areas as compared to the large number of samples of raw milk sampled in Sabon gari and Zaria local government areas, which gave a statistically significant association between the isolation rate for L. monocytogenes and the local government areas (P<0.0413) (Table 3).

The Microbact 12L Listeria identification kit was able to identify 3 (8.3%) out of 36 biochemically identified isolates as L. monocytogenes, while the rest were identified as non- L. monocytogenes (Listeria grayi 4 (11.0%), Listeria ivanovii 27 (75.0%) and Listeria seeligeri 2 (6.0%)). The identification rate of 3 (8.3%) for L. monocytogenes obtained in this study by the Microbact system is lower than 12 (30.0%) obtained by [44] out of the 40 L. monocytogenes isolates from raw meat and meat products in Zaria, Nigeria. The applicability of Microbact 12L (Oxoid) for identification of Listeria monocytogenes in this environment requires reconsideration and validation. Reference [45] also obtained a prevalence of 39(13.0%) for L. monocytogenes out of 400 abattoir chicken isolates from Khartoum, Sudan. In this study L. ivanovii had the highest identification rate of 75.0%, which is similar to the study of [44, 45], where L. ivanovii had the highest identification rate of 47.5% and 48.5% respectively.

The identification of L. ivanovii and other supposedly non-pathogenic Listeria species (L. seeligeri and L. grayi) is significant, since these non-pathogenic Listeria species like L. grayi, L. seeligeri and L. innocua have been found to cause disease in both immunocompetent and immunocompromised individuals [46].

From the perspective of food hygiene, the presence of non-pathogenic species such as L. innocua may indicate potential contamination with L. monocytogenes [47]. L. ivanovii is pathogenic for animals and it has been reported to be associated with gastroenteritis and bacteraemia in a 55 year old man with renal transplant [48].

Listeriolysin O (LLO) produced by Listeria monocytogenes and encoded by hly A gene, is one of the most virulent factors associated with the organism. One of the best ways to detect and confirm Listeria monocytogenes is through the detection of the virulence factors. The LLO –encoding gene (hly A) is present only in virulent strains of the species and is required for virulence [49, 50].

In this study the multiplex PCR identified 9 Listeria monocytogenes isolates harbouring hly A gene. The amplified genes for L. monocytogenes and Listeria genus produced PCR products of 702bp and 938bp in size respectively. The PCR protocol used in this study was based on the amplification of hly A gene by using a set of primers, LM1 and LM2. Reference [29] recommended LM1 and LM2 primers as the best primer pair to be used for the detection of L. monocytogenes, because they are designed to amplify specific fragments in L. monocytogenes strains that are genetically and biochemically assessed as belonging to this specie, on the basis of the presence of the 702bp and 938bp amplicons [29].

Reference [51] was also able to amplify the DNA at their expected amplification site. The result of this study is not in agreement with the result of [52], who reported the carriage of hly A gene by all the isolates of L. monocytogenes tested. The inability of some of the L. monocytogenes isolates in this study to harbour the hly A gene, may be due to the non virulent characteristics of some L. monocytogenes isolates; because some may be environmental isolates or it may be possible that some L. monocytogenes strains may lack one or more virulence determinants because of spontaneous mutations [53].

In this study, the antibiotic susceptibility testing showed that all the isolates were resistant to ampicillin, followed by resistance to penicillin (95%). The least frequency of resistance by the isolates was obtained for streptomycin (17.5%) and chloramphenicol (25%) (Figure 1). A high rate of resistance to ampicillin (100%) is agreement with the result of [39, 40] where they reported that all the isolates from milk sold in Sokoto, Nigeria and processed meat sold in Selangor, Malaysia respectively were reported to be resistant to ampicillin. Similarly reference [54] in their study of antibiotic resistance of L. monocytogenes isolates from salad vegetables and vegetable salads in Zaria reported the organisms to be resistant to ampicillin (92.9%), erythromycin (64.3%), penicillin (85.0%) and tetracycline (75.0%).

Reference [55] reported that all the isolates from various foods were susceptible to erythromycin; this is at par with the results obtained in this study where 77.5% of the L. monocytogenes isolates were resistant to erythromycin. Reference [44, 56, 57] all observed a 100% susceptibility of Listeria monocytogenes isolates to gentamicin, which is not in agreement with the results obtained in this study, where 32.5% of the isolates were resistant to gentamicin. The study of [56], reported a favourable activity of penicillin and ampicillin against L. monocytogenes, which is contrary to the findings of the present study, where all the isolates were resistant to ampicillin (100%), 95% to penicillin and 72.5% to sulfamethoxazole. The detection of L. monocytogenes resistant to sulfamethoxazole in this study is of particular interest, since the combination of trimethoprim-sulfamethaxozole is the second choice drug of treatment for ampicillin/penicillin resistant strains and also used in patients with allergy to penicillin [58].

It is assumed that the high prevalence of antibiotic resistance observed among the isolates in this study may not be unconnected with the indiscriminate use and abuse of these antibiotics in livestock production in Nigeria as the case in Denmark [59]. When infections are caused by L. monocytogenes strains resistant to the first choice drugs, more expensive therapies must be used, also a longer duration of illness and treatment in hospitals, increases health care cost which will result in economic burden on the families and society [60].

A total of 34 antibiograms observed in this study, revealed a high diversity of antimicrobial resistance of the L. monocytogenes isolates. Since the first isolation of a multi-resistant strain of L. monocytogenes in France in 1988 [61], multi-resistant strains have been extensively isolated. All the 36 L. monocytogenes isolates were multidrug resistant. Reference [39] also reported that 20% of the L. monocytogenes isolates from dairy products in Sokoto were resistant to more than two antibiotic agents and all the isolates were resistant to at least one antibiotic agent. Reference [54] also reported that 64.3% of the isolates were resistant to more than 4 antibiotic agents and all the isolates (100%) were resistant to more than two antimicrobial agents. The data obtained in this study on antimicrobial resistance suggest the importance of continued surveillance of emerging antibiotic resistance in L. monocytogenes in order to control the pathogen and ensure effective treatment of human listeriosis.

The MAR index was determined for the 36 L. monocytogenes isolates. The results revealed that 32 (88.9%) of the isolates had MAR index higher than 0.2, an indication that these isolates originated from a high risk source of contamination e.g., farm animals that are exposed to antibiotics [62, 63][62, 63].

Multiple antibiotic resistances in Listeria spp has been attributed to antimicrobial selective pressure and gene transfer mechanisms between and among Listeria species and close relatives, such as Enterococcus, Staphylococcus and Streptococcus species [64]. The high MAR index observed in most of the isolates with the exception of four isolates (MDGM123, SGHR 32, SGHR 39 and MDGR115) is an indication that even though few of the isolates were not multi drug resistant, almost all the isolates would have spread from an environment of high antibiotic use or from high risk sources of contamination. Hence, it was not surprising to find 53.3% of these high MAR index isolates originated from the raw milk samples. Infections caused by resistant microorganisms may result in failure to respond to treatment, result in prolonged illness, higher health care expenditure and greater risk of death [65].

In conclusion, the study has demonstrated the presence and distribution of Listeria monocytogenes and other Listeria species in raw milk and milk products in the area, this suggest the need for improved milk safety through the implementation of hygienic measures at all level from production to consumption with particular emphasis on ready to eat milk and milk products. Also the isolation of Listeria monocytogenes strains that are resistant to ampicillin and penicillin are of great concern, since these two antibiotics are the treatment of choice for listeriosis in combined with an amino glycoside. L. monocytogenes presence in RTE foods is of public health concern as these food items are consumed without previous heat treatment

References

[1]  Babatunde, G. M., Oyenuga, V. A. and Loosli, J. K. (1999). Problems and possibility for milk production. Animal Production in the Tropics, 1: 43-60.
In article      
 
[2]  Donkor, E. S., Aning, K. G. and Quaye, J. (2007). Bacterial contamination of informally marketed raw milk in Ghana. Ghana Journal 41: 58-61.
In article      
 
[3]  Scuk, 2007. Evaluation of community resettlement and reintegration Programme activities. Scuk Jigiga Area Programme. Addis Ababa, SC, UK Ethiopia.
In article      
 
[4]  Adetunji, V. O. and Arigbede, M. I. (2011). Occurrence of E. coli O157:H7 and Listeria monocytogenes and Identification of Hazard Analysis Critical Control Points (HACCPs) in Production Operations of a Typical Tropic Cheese ‘Wara’ and Yoghurt. Pakistan Journal of Nutrition, 10: 796-804
In article      
 
[5]  Savadogo, A., Ouattaracherk, A. T., Paul, W., Baro, N. O., S. and Aboubacar, T., Alfred, S. (2004). Microorganisms involved in Fulani fermented milk in Burkina Faso. Pakistani Journal of Nutrition, 3:134-139.
In article      
 
[6]  Graves, L. M., Heelsel, L. O., Steigerwait, A. G., Morey, R. E., Daneshvar, M. L., Roof, S. E., Orsi, R. H., Fortes, E. D. and Milillo, S.R. (2010). Listeria marthii spp. nov., isolated from the natural environment of Finger Lakes National Forest. International Journal of Systemic and Evolutionary Microbiology, 60: 1280-1288.
In article      
 
[7]  Leclercq, A., Clermont, D., Bizet, C., Drimont, B., Le Fleche-Mateos, A., Roche, S., Buchrieser, C., Cadet-Daniel, V., Le Monnier, A., Lecuit, M., and allerberger, F. (2009). Cited by Henk, C. D., Bundrant, B. N., Fortes, E. D., Orsi, R. H., and Wiedmann, M. (2010). A population genetics- based and phylogenetic approach to understanding the evolution of virulence in the genus Listeria. Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 76: 6085-6100.
In article      
 
[8]  Bertsch, D., Rau, J., Eugster, M. R., Haug, M. C., Lason, P. A., Lacroix, C. and Meile, I. (2013). Listeria fleischmannii spp nov., isolated from cheese. International Journal Systemic and Evolutionary Microbiology, 63: 526-532.
In article      
 
[9]  Lang Halter, E., Neuhanus, K. and Scherer, S. (2013). Listeria weihenstephanensis sp novi., isolated from the water plant Lemma trisulca taken from a freshwater pond. International Journal of Systemic and Evolutionary Microbiology, 63: 641-647.
In article      
 
[10]  Henk, C. B., Warchocki, S., Wright, E. M., Allied, A. F., Ahlstrom, C., Manuel, C. S., Stasiewicz, M. J., Burrel, A., Roof, S., Strawn, L. K., Fortes, E., Nightingale, K. K., Kephart, D. and Wiedmann, M. (2014). Five new species of Listeria (L. floridensis sp, nov, L. aquqtica sp, nov., L. cornellensis sp. Nov. L. riparia sp, nov. and L. grandensis sp. Nov.) from agriculture and natural environment in the United States. IJSEM Papers in Press, Published March 5, 2014.
In article      
 
[11]  Schmid, M. W., Ng, E. Y., Lapidis, R., Emmerth, M., Walcher, M., Kreft, J., Goebel, W., Wagner, M. and Schleifer, K. H. (2005). Evolutionary history of genus Listeria and its virulence genes. Systemic Applied Microbiology, 28; 1-18.
In article      View Article  PubMed
 
[12]  Dominquez-Bernal, G., Stefanie, M. A., Bruno G. Z., Mariela S., Petra, H., Hector, J. M., Lizeth, L. Jurgn K. And Vazque- Boland J. A. (2006). A spontaneous genomic deletion in Listeria ivanovii identities LIPI-2, a specie-specific pathogenicity island encoding sphingongelinase and numerous internalins. Molecular Microbiology, 59: 415-432.
In article      
 
[13]  Food and Agriculture Organisations (1999). Report of the FAO expert consultation on the trade Impact of Listeria in fish products. FAO fisheries report NO. 64Fillu/ESNS/R604.Amsherst, M.A United states PP 17-20
In article      
 
[14]  Abay, S., Aydin, F., and Sumerkan, A. B (2012). Molecular typing of Listeria spp. isolated from different sources. Ankara Üniv Vet FakDerg, 59: 183-190.
In article      
 
[15]  Olive,r S. P., Jayaro, B. M. and Almeida, R. A. (2005). Food-borne pathogens in milk and the dairy farm environment: food safety and public health implications. Foodborne Pathologic Disease, 2: 115.
In article      
 
[16]  Aygun O, and Serda, P. (2006). Listeria spp. in the raw milk and dairy products in Antakya, Turkey. Food Control, 17: 676-678.
In article      
 
[17]  Scallan, E., Hoekstra, R. M., Angulo, F. J., Tauxe, R. V., Widdowso, M. A., Roy, S. L., Jones, J. L., and Griffin P. M. (2011). Food- borne illnesses acquired in the United States-Major pathogens. Emerging Infectious Diseases, 17: 7–15.
In article      
 
[18]  Obi, C. N. and Ikenebom, M. J. (2007). Studies on the Microbiology and Nutritional Qualities of a Nigerian fermented milk product (Nono). International Journal of Dairy Science, 2, 95-99.
In article      
 
[19]  Cartwright, E., Jackson, K. A., Johnson, S. D., Graves, L. M., Silk, B.J. and Mahon. E. B. (2013). Listeriosis outbreaks and associated food vehicles, United States, 1998–. 2008. Emerging Infectious Disease, 19: 1-9.
In article      
 
[20]  Silk, B. J., Date, K. A., Jackson, K. A., Pouillot, R., Kristin, G. H., Lewis, M. G. (2012). Invasive listeriosis in Foodborne Diseases Active Surveillance Network (Food Net), 2004-2009: Further Targeted Prevention Needed for Higher-Risk Groups. Clinical Infectious Disease, 54: 396-404.
In article      
 
[21]  Jalali, M. and Abedi, D. (2008). Prevalence of Listeria species in food products in Isfahan, Iran. International Journal of Food Microbiology, 122: 336-340.
In article      
 
[22]  CDC (2013). Incidence and trends of infection with pathogens transmitted commonly through food. Foodborne Diseases Active Surveillance Network, 10 U.S. sites, 1996–2012. MMWR 62, 283-287.
In article      
 
[23]  Hof, H., Nichterlein, T. and Kretschmar, M. (1997). Management of listeriosis. Clinical Microbiology Review, 10: 345-357.
In article      
 
[24]  Morvan, A., Moubareck, C., Leclercq, A., Hervé-Bazin, M., Bremont, S., Lecuit, M. (2010). Antimicrobial resistance of Listeria monocytogenes strains isolated from humans in France. Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy, 54; 272-2731.
In article      View Article  PubMed
 
[25]  Troxler,R.,vonGraevenitz, A., Funke,G.,Wiedemann, B., Stock, I. (2000). Natural antibiotic susceptibility of Listeria species: L. grayi, L. innocua, L. ivanovii, L. monocytogenes. seeligeri and L. welshimeri strains. Clinical. Microbiology Infection. 6, 525e535.
In article      
 
[26]  Pesavento, G. Doci, B. Nieri, O. Comodo, N. and Lo Nostro, A. (2010). Prevalence and antibiotic susceptibility of Listeria spp. isolated from raw meat and retail foods. Food Control. 21:708-713.
In article      
 
[27]  Roberts, D., W. Hoper and Greenwood, M. (1995). Practical food microbiology. London: Public health Laboratory Services, pp: 146-149.
In article      
 
[28]  Janzten, M. M., Navas, J., Corujo, A., Moreno, R., López, V. and Martínez-Suárez, J. V. (2006). Review. Specific detection of Listeria monocytogenes in foods using commercial methods: from chromogenic media to real-time PCR. Spanish Journal of Agriculture. Research, 4:235-247.
In article      
 
[29]  Border, P., M., Howard, J., J., Plastow, G., S. and Siggens, K., W. (1990). Detection of Listeria species and Listeria monocytogenes using polymerase chain reaction. Letters in Applied Microbiology; 11:158-162.
In article      
 
[30]  Bauer, A., Kirby, W., Sherris, J., C., and Turck, M. (1966). Antibiotic susceptibility testing by a standardized single disk method. American journal of clinical pathology, 45(4):493.
In article      
 
[31]  (CLSI) Clinical Laboratory Standards Institute (2011). Performance standards for antimicrobial disk susceptibility tests; Approved standard- 9th Ed. CLSI document M2-A9. 26:1. Clinical Laboratory Standards Institute, Wayne, PA.
In article      
 
[32]  Conter, M., Paludi, D., Zanardi, E., Ghidini, S., Vergara, A. and Ianieri, A. (2009). Characterization of antimicrobial resistance of foodborne Listeria monocytogenes. International Journal of Food Microbiology, 128: 497-500.
In article      
 
[33]  Singh, S., Vadar, Singh, S. and Bharti, P. (2010). Prevalence of Salmonella in chicken eggs collected from poultry farms and marketing channels and their antimicrobial resistance. Food Research International, 43:2027-2030.
In article      
 
[34]  Jamali, H., Chai, L. C. and Thong, K. L. (2013). Detection and isolation of Listeria spp. and Listeria monocytogenes in ready-to-eat foods with various selective culture media. Food Control, 32: 19-24.
In article      
 
[35]  Boubendir, A., Hamidechi, M. A., Mostakim, M., El Abed, S., Ibnsouda Koraichi, S. (2011). Incidence of Listeria species and other psychrotrohic bacteria in bovine raw milk products in Northern Eastern Algeria. Medical Veterinary Review, 162:265-269.
In article      
 
[36]  Ning, N., Guo, K., Chug, L., Xu, L., Zhag, C., Cui, H., Cheng, Y., R., Liu, Q., Cio, W. and Zheng, Y. (2013). Pilot survey of raw whole milk in China from L. monocytogenes using PCR. Food Control, 31:176-179.
In article      
 
[37]  Benkeroum, N., Oubel, H., Zahar, M., Dlia, S. and Filali- Maltoul, A. (2003). Isolation of a bacteriocin producing Lactococcus lactis subsp. Lactis and application to control Listeria monocytogenes in Moroccan jben. Journal of Applied Microbiology, 89 (6): 960-968.
In article      
 
[38]  Adetunji, V. O. and Olaoye, O. O. (2012). Incidence and antibiotic susceptibility of Listeria monocytogenes isolates from milk of West African dwarf and red Sokoto breeds of goat from South-western Nigeria. New York Science Journal, 5 (11): 68-73.
In article      
 
[39]  Yakubu, Y., Salihu, M. D., Faleke, O. O., Abubakar, M. B., Junaidu, A. U., Magaji, A. A., Gulumbe, M. L. and Aliyu, R. M. (2012). Prevalence and antibiotic susceptibility of Listeria monocytogenes in raw milk from cattle herds within Sokoto Metropolis, Nigeria. Sokoto Journal of Veterinary Sciences, 10:13-17.
In article      
 
[40]  Issa, Z. M., Mustakim, M., Mohamed, S. A. S., Muda, N. M., Yen, L. H. and Radu, S. (2011). Antibiograms profiles of Listeria monocytogenes isolated from foods. International Conference on Biotechnology and Food Science (IPCBEE), 7: 133-137.
In article      
 
[41]  Kalorey, D. R., Warke, S. R., Kurkure, N. V., Rawool, D. B. and Barbuddhe, S. B. (2008). Listeria species in bovine raw milk: A large survey of Central India. Food Control, 19: 109-112.
In article      
 
[42]  Sauders, B. D., Durak, M. Z., Fortes, E., Windham, K., Schukken, Y. and Lembo, A. J. (2006). Molecular characterisation of Listeria monocytogenes from natura l and urban environment. Journal of Food Protection, 69: 93-105.
In article      
 
[43]  Kasalica, A., Vukovic, V., Vranjes, A. and Memisi, N. (2011). Listeria monocytogenes in milk and dairy products. Biotechnology in Animal Husbandry, 27: 1067-1082.
In article      
 
[44]  Ndahi, M. D., Kwaga, J. K. P., Bello, M., Kabir, J., Umoh, V. J., Yakubu, S. E. and Nok A. J. (2013). Prevalence and antimicrobial susceptibility of Listeria monocytogenes and methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus strains from raw meat and meat products in Zaria, Nigeria. Letters in Applied Microbiology, 58(3): 263-269.
In article      
 
[45]  Al sheikh, A. D. I., Mohammed, G. E. and Abdalla, A. (2012). Isolation and identification of L. monocytogenes from fresh raw dressed broiler chicken in Sudan. Research Journal of Microbiology, 7: 319-326.
In article      
 
[46]  Perrin, M., Berner, M. and Delamare, C. (2003). Fatel case of Listeria innocua bacteraemia. Journal of Clinical Microbiology, 41: 5308-5309.
In article      
 
[47]  Gasanov, U., Hughes, D. and Hansbro, M. P. (2005). Methods for the isolation and identification of Listeria spp. and Listeria monocytogenes: a review. FEMS Microbiology Reviews, 29: 851-875.
In article      
 
[48]  Christelle, G., Join-Lambert, O., Monnier, A., Leclercq, A., Mechai, F., Mamzer- Bruneel, M., Bielecka, M., Scortti, Mariela, Dission, O. Berche, P., Vazquez- Boland, J., Lortholary, O. and Lecuit, M. (2010). Human listeriosis caused by Listeria ivanovii. Emerging infectious Diseases, 166(1): 136-138.
In article      
 
[49]  Jay, J. (1996). Modern food microbiology. In: Heldman DR, editor. Foodborne Listeriosis. New York: Chapman& Hall, pp: 478-506.
In article      View Article
 
[50]  Mengaud, J., M. F. Vicente, J. Chenevert, J. Pereira, C. Geoffroy, B. Gicquel-Sanzey, F. Baquero, J. C. Perez-Diaz and and P. Cossart, (1988). Expression in Escherichia coli and sequence analysis of the listeriolysin O determinant of Listeria monocytogenes. Infection and Immunity, 56: 766-772.
In article      
 
[51]  Kuan, C., H., Goh, S., G., Loo, Y., Y., et al. (2013). Prevalence and quantification of L. monocytogenes in chicken offal at retail level in Malaysia. Poultry Science 2013; 92: 1664-1669.
In article      
 
[52]  Jallewor, P., K., Kalorey, D., R., Kurkure, N., V., Pande, V., V. and Barbuddhe, S., B. (2007). Genotypic characterisation of Listeria spp isolated from fresh water fish. International Journal of Food Microbiology, 114: 120-123.
In article      
 
[53]  Cooray, K. J., Nishibori, T., Xiong, H., Matsuyama, T., Fujita, M., and Mitsuyama, M. (1994). Detection of multiple virulence associated genes of Listeria monocytogenes by PCR in artificially contaminated milk samples. Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 60: 3023–3026.
In article      
 
[54]  Ieren, I. I., Bello, M. and Kwaga, J. K. P. (2013). Occurrence and antibiotic resistance profile of Listeria monocytogenes in salad vegetables and vegetable salads sold in Zaria, Nigeria. African Journal of Food Science, 7: 334-338.
In article      
 
[55]  Morobe, I. C., Obi, C. I., Nyila, M. A., Mataheka, M. I. and Gashe, B. A. (2009). Prevalence and antimicrobial resistance profiles of L. monocytogenes from various foods in Gaborone, Botswana. African Journal of Biotechnology, 8: (22)6383-6387.
In article      
 
[56]  Aureli, P., Ferrini, A. M. and Mannoni, V. (2003). Susceptibility of L. monocytogenes isolated from food in Italy to antimicrobial agents. International Journal of Food Microbiology, 83: 325-330.
In article      
 
[57]  Ennaji, H. H., Timinouni, M., Ennaji, M., Hassar, M. and Cohen, N. (2008). Characterization and antibiotic susceptibility of Listeria monocytogenes isolated from poultry and red meat in Morocco. Infection and Drug Resistance, 1: 45-50. 26.
In article      
 
[58]  Charpentier, E., Gerbaud, G., Jacquect, C., Rocourt, J. and Courvalin, P. (1995). Incidence of antibiotic resistance in Listeria spp. Journal of Infectious Diseases, 172: 277-289.
In article      
 
[59]  Levy, S. B. (2014). Reduced antibiotics use in livestock: How Denmark tackled resistance. Environmental Health Perspectives, 122. 6.
In article      View Article  PubMed
 
[60]  Adzitey, F., Hudu, N. and Ali, G. R. R. (2012). Prevalence and antibiotic resistance of Campylobacter, Salmonella and Listeria monocytogenes in ducks- A review. Foodborne Pathogen Disease, 9: 498-505.
In article      
 
[61]  Poyart-Salmeron, C., Carlier, C., Trieu-Cuot, P. and Courvalin, P. (1990). Transferable plasmid-mediated antibiotic resistance in Listeria monocytogenes. Lancet, 335: 1422-1426.
In article      
 
[62]  Wong, W. C., Pui, C. F., Tunung, R., Ubong, A., Noor Hidayah, M. S., Farinazleen, M. G., Noorlis, A., Cheah, Y. K. and Son, R. (2012). Antibiograms pattern among cultures of Listeria monocytogenes isolated from frozen burger patties in Malaysia. Pertanika. Journal of Tropical Agricultural Science, 35 (4): 793 – 804.
In article      
 
[63]  Krumperman, P. H. (1983). Multiple antibiotics resistance indexing Escherichia coli to identify risk sources of faecal contamination of foods. Applied Environmental Microbiology, 46: 165-170.
In article      
 
[64]  Safdar. A. and Arms Armstrong, D. (2003). Antimicrobial activities against 84 Listeria monocytogenes isolates from patient with systemic listeriosis at a comprehensive cancer centre (1955-1997). Journal of clinical microbiology, 41:483-85
In article      View Article  PubMed
 
[65]  Adzitey, F., Huda, Ali, N. G. R. R. and Manual, C. S. (2013). Isolation and characterisation of unidentified Listeria strains showing phenotypic and genetic similarities to a novel group of Listeria species from Malaysian Peking ducks. Journal of Biological Sciences, 13: 614-620.
In article      
 

Appendix

Appendix 1. Antibacterial resistance patterns (Antibiograms) of 36 L. monocytogenes isolates from raw milk and milk products

Appendix 2. MAR Index Analysis of L. monocytogenes isolates from raw milk and milk products Samples

  • CiteULikeCiteULike
  • MendeleyMendeley
  • StumbleUponStumbleUpon
  • Add to DeliciousDelicious
  • FacebookFacebook
  • TwitterTwitter
  • LinkedInLinkedIn