Abstract

This article describes the development and implementation of auto-grade online chemical equation questions, created by using Fill in Multiple Blanks question options on the Blackboard Software. Five categories of questions other than multiple choice questions were effectively implemented in online assessments. This kind of questions may be used for large class online home works, tutorials, and proctored-quizzes.

1. Introduction

Homework for a very large group of students has quite number of challenges that ranges from difficulties in grading ¹ to problems of students copying each other without actually solving the questions themselves. The advent of the internet age has made the use of online homework has become more commonplace in General Chemistry course. ² Online homework has been shown to have clear advantages over the traditional paper homework to increase efficiency in distributing, collecting and grading. ³

Multiple-choice questions (MCQs) are the predominate form for practical applications of online knowledge assessment, even though there are indications that this form of assessment predominantly tests only lower levels of cognitive skills. ⁴ MCQs mainly stimulate the appearance of surface learning strategy. On the other hand, online assessments in the form of an essay mainly stimulate the appearance of deep learning strategy. ⁴

This paper focused is on how to create auto-graded online chemical equation questions, which are not MCQs, by using Blackboard Fill in Multiple Blanks options. Solutions to some limitations and problems were also discussed therein. The questions are part of online homework questions successfully deployed to our students, numbering 350-450 students per semester, in the last two semesters, by the Department of General Studies of Jubail Industrial College, Jubail, Saudi Arabia.

2. Fill in Multiple Blanks and Chemical Equations

For Fill in Multiple Blanks questions, students are presented with text containing up to 10 blanks, in which they type appropriate words, phrases or numbers. Student’s answers are graded automatically, by matching with answers already provided by the instructor. ⁵

The potential types of questions are:

1. Balancing numerical in chemical equations

2. Completing and balancing one product

3. Completing and balancing two products

4. Converting word questions to chemical equations

5. Classifying chemical reactions.

i. Balancing numerical in chemical equations

There is no sequence of rules that can be followed blindly to get a balanced chemical equation. All we can do is manipulate the coefficients written in front of the formulas of reactants and products, until the number of atoms of each element on both sides of the equation are the same ⁶ (numerical balancing).

The stoichiometric coefficient of Fe₂S₃ Question 1a is 1, leaving cell without a variable also implied 1, but the Blackboard Fill in Multiple Blanks does not accept blank, a variable should be written in the blank (cell), therefore, we have to provide the value 1 as in Question 1b (coefficient of Al₄C₃), or not providing a cell, as in question 1a (coefficient of Fe₂S₃), Figure 1.

ii. Completing and balancing one products

In writing the product of combination reactions, compounds should be represented by their correct chemical formulas, which are written on the basis of valences (i.e. combining capacities of the interacting elements or charges of their ions). ⁷ For example in Question 2a, aluminum has a valence of +3 and oxygen a valence of +2, so the formula of aluminum oxide is Al₂O₃. One limitation of the Blackboard is the inability of the examinees to write the number of atoms in the subscript forms.

In addition reactions, products should be written in their molecular formulas (compounds are written by grouping the atoms of the same elements together). For example, the molecular formula of ethanol is C₂H₆O. However, Chemist often writes it condensed molecular formula as CH₃CH₂OH (or in a more abbreviated for as C₂H₅OH). This kind of representation tells us how atoms in the molecules are linked. ⁸ The other possible answers provided by the examiner on this questions are: HOCH₂CH₃, CH₃CH₂-OH, HO-CH₂CH₃, CH₃-CH₂-OH, CH₂(OH)CH₃, C₂H₅ –OH, etc. To avoid difficulties, the answer needs to be kept simple and brief, ⁵ however the simple molecular formula (C₂H₆O) is the best option (Figure 2).

iii. Completing and balancing two products

The problem that could arise in completing and balancing two products is deciding which of the product will be written first, this problem can be solved if the states of the products are different, which is the case in most of the reactions. Therefore the product that should be written first is directed by the state. In question 3, CO₂ will come first before water, because of the state of CO₂ (g) was place in the first cell, Figure 3. The limitation of typing subscript is present here too.

iv. Converting word questions to chemical equations

In Question 4, reactants are Ca(OH)₂ and HNO₃, both reactant states are aqueous (aq), the problem is which of the reactants should be written first, the way out of this is to provide both answers (variables, Ca(OH)₂ and HNO₃) in both blacks, as it is very unlikely for examinee to write acid or base in both cells, Figure 4. The subscript limitation is also a problem in this type of questions.

v. Classification of chemical reactions

Several general types of chemical reactions can occur based on what happens when going from reactants to products. ⁹ Combustion reactions can easily be identified by the presence of O₂ on the reactant side, CO₂ and H₂O on the product side, Question 5a.

The variables that can be provided for Question 5b by the examiner are combination, synthesis or addition. A more active element displaces another less active element in a compound hence the answers provided by the examiner to Question 5c could be replacement, single replacement, displacement or substitution (reactions), Figure 5.

3. Limitations

• Inability of the examinee to write subscripts for the number of atoms in the chemical formulas.

• The cells cannot be left without variables even if the coefficient in the equation is 1.

• Lack of control on the size of the cells.

Associate Content

Pdf file for the sample questions is available on the internet. Step by step on how to create Fill in Multiple Blank Questions can be found in reference ⁵.

Acknowledgments

Facilities provided by Jubail Industrial College of Royal Commission for Jubail and Yanbu are gratefully acknowledged. The author is grateful to Dr. Yunusa Umar and Mr. Rizan Abdul Rahid for their help during preparation of the manuscript.

References