A European Perspective on the Higher Education in Romania

Veiw figure View Table

Table 2. Qualifications of the three cycle in the Romanian higher education

Download as

Veiw figure View Table

Table 3. Types of diplomas in Romania

Download as

Veiw figure View Table

2.3. Types of Diplomas and Awards

The qualifications acquired by the graduates of higher education study programmes in Romania are attested by 3 types of diplomas: Bachelor/engineer/medical doctor, urban planner diploma, Master diploma and PhD diploma (Table 3). Besides the three study cycles, competences acquired through post-university continuing training and personal development studies do not lead to qualifications, but are attested by certificates and other documents. These documents are issued only by accredited higher education institutions and only for accredited study programmes and modes, according to the National Education Law 1/2011 ^[9].

The university categories issuing diplomas and certificates are universities focused on education; tertiary education institutions focused on education and scientific research /or focused on education and artistic creation, and universities focused on advanced research and education.

3. The Framework of Qualifications for the European Higher Education Area and the National Qualification Framework

The Qualifications Framework in the European Higher Education Area (QF/EHEA) was adopted in 2005 by European Ministers of Education, and the European Qualifications Framework for Lifelong Learning (EQF) was published in 2008 as the full development of the National Qualifications Framework (NQF) covering all eight levels of qualification. Based on the EQF, the National Qualifications Framework was developed by the National Agency for Qualification in Higher Education (ACPART) at the end of 2005. The Executive Unit of the National Qualifications and Adult Training Council (UECNCFPA) became the National Coordination Point for the NQF in 2010. NQF is an instrument for the classification of qualifications against a set of criteria related to specific learning levels from a lifelong learning perspective, in order to provide international transparency of the learning outcomes, according to the 2011 law in education.

The National Qualification Framework was developed since 2006 in order to be fully compliant with requirements stated by the Bergen Report. The first draft of the Self certification Report was drafted and official launched in 2011. The NQF is fully compatible with the European Framework for Higher Education ^[10]. Qualifications compatibility aim to facilitate the mobility of students and workers in the EU, to stimulate “brain mobility” and fair employment, especially of youth. A comprehensive description of the learning outcomes for each study programme is supported by an electronic platform: the National Register of Qualifications in Higher Education –RNCIS.

3.1. Learning Outcomes

Table 4. The framework of qualifications for the European Higher Education Area

Download as

Veiw figure View Table

Learning outcomes in the European education area usually represent sets of competences acquired on completion of the studies. The workload is the average time an average learner might be expected to need in order to reach the required learning outcomes of a full-time student during one academic year (according to European Network of Information Centres in the European Region). In the Bologna Process there is no requirement for any minimum student learning hours. The number of ECTS credits awarded depends on qualification level and study programme and is only shown after appropriate assessment of the learning outcomes. In Table 4 are shown the learning outcomes in the European Higher Education Area Framework ^[11].

3.2. The European Credit Transfer and Accumulation System (ECTS)

The European Credit Transfer and Accumulation System is tool for transfer of study achievements, but also for accumulation of workload in the first and second and in the third cycles throughout the area of European higher education. ECTS was established before the Bologna process started as a tool for transfer of study achievements for the Erasmus/Socrates programme. ECTS credits were linked to the workload as a basis for their calculation (ECTS Users’ Guide 2005), whereas in 2009 it was specified that “the formulation of learning outcomes is the basis for the estimation of workload and hence for credit allocation” (ECTS Users’ Guide 2009). Learning outcomes are linked to implementation of qualifications frameworks and to the paradigm shift towards student-centred learning approach ^[12].

In Romania, learning outcomes means statements of what a learner knows, understands and is able to do on completion of a learning process, which are defined in terms of knowledge, skills and competence ^[13].

All higher education institutions use ECTS for accumulation and transfer for all elements of study programmes. The basis to award ECTS is a combination of learning outcomes and student workload. There is no standard measurement for the number of hours per credit but the reported number of hours per credit is 27 ^[14].

3.3. Diploma Supplement

All national higher education institutions issue free of charge the Diploma Supplement for their graduates from bachelor and master programs ^[15]. The Diploma Supplement is issued in Romanian language and usually in English, but could be also in French or German.

In Romania, the Diploma Supplement is a compulsory document for all diplomas of bachelor ^[16], and master programs ^[17], and for diplomas of professions regulated by European norms, regulations or good practices – where bachelor and master programs can be provided as part of a 5 to 6 year full-time programme of study, those diplomas are recognized as master’s degree certificates (as in the following fields of study: Medicine, Dentistry, Pharmacy, Veterinary Medicine, Architecture.

3.4. Compliance of Compatibility Criteria (Recognition of Qualifications)

In Romania, the academic and professional recognition is done by the Ministry of Education through the ENIC/NARIC centre for non-regulated professions ^[18]. The competent authorities for the regulated professions take the decision of recognition for EU citizens. The recognition conditions are stated in the law implementing the Lisbon Convention no. 172/1998 and also there are some references in the Law of national education no. 1/2011. Based on the law implementing the Lisbon Convention, the National Centre ENIC/NARIC has adopted the methodology on the recognition of diplomas through a Ministry Order ^[19].

Issues on fostering flexible learning and access routes to higher education (such as entry with a school leaving certificate, entry with a vocational education certificate, entry without formal certification etc.) are not regulated by policy measures. There isn’t yet any official status on part-time study provision nor an explicit policy to encourage part-time study provision by higher education institutions. Recognition of prior non-formal and informal learning is not yet defined in legislation which neither expressly permits nor prohibits HEIS to implement procedures for validation of non-formal and informal learning.

Widening access to education in order to enable a broader range of individuals to fulfill their potential is a Bologna desiderate. Postgraduate trainings and professional development programmes provided by higher education institutions in the framework of the Lifelong learning process are taken into consideration especially by employed and unemployed adults, and less by retired citizens, part-time students or adults without higher education qualifications.

3.5. Academic Recognition

Academic recognition is the evaluation of a diploma/degree obtained abroad in order to determine the equivalent level in the domestic education system by the competent Romanian authority (National Centre for Recognition and Equivalence of Diplomas-CNRED ^[20].

Foreign degrees are evaluated in terms of the institution status; level of the diploma; no of years of study/no of credits accumulated; field of study; study profile; specialization; curriculum/ workload/ Diploma Supplement; professional qualification. In case of major differences in field and profile, compensatory measures can be proposed: periods of study or aptitude tests/exams, which are applied by accredited universities in Romania. In case of bilateral agreements the recognition of studies and diplomas is done automatically. Bilateral agreements and conventions to which Romania is part of have been enacted with Hungary, Moldova, Bulgaria, Ukraine, Cyprus, Slovakia and Russian Federation. The tools used in recognition are the National Qualifications Framework for Higher Education (NQF), the European system of transferable academic credits (ECTS) and Diploma Supplement ^[21].

3.6. Recognition of Professional Qualifications

Professional recognition is taken into consideration the level of the diploma and the professional experience acquired in other state in order to exercise a profession in Romania. CNRED is the competent authority for professional recognition of qualifications obtained abroad, in order to obtain the work permit issued by the Ministry of Labor.

For the recognition of university academic titles obtained in a Higher Education Institution accredited in a Member State of the European Union, of the European Economic Area and in the Swiss Confederation the competent authority is the National Centre for Recognition and Equivalence of Diplomas - CNRED. Certificate of conformity with the European Union directives are issued for non-regulated professional activities in Romania.

A regulated profession is the activity/group of professional activities, whose right to exercise/one of the means of exercising them are conditioned by the possession of specific professional qualifications. For the regulated professions in Romania (doctor, dentist, pharmacist, nurse, midwife, veterinarian doctor and architect) the Certificate of conformity can be issued by the corresponding competent authorities, according to the Law no. 200/2004: Ministry of Health, Order of Architects etc.

3.7. Quality Assurance

The internal quality assurance processes for the internal approval monitoring and periodic review of programmes is conducted by Quality Assurance Departments (or Committees) at university level. External review is also in place.

The Romanian Agency for Quality Assurance - an independent public institution ^[22], verifies the compliance by the evaluated study-programme of criteria and standards set legally, according to the ESG. If all criteria are met, the study-programme/institution is granted an accreditation in order to enroll students, deliver courses and organize final exams and deliver degrees at the end of the cycles, or in case of provisional authorization, to enroll students and deliver courses. Every five years, all accredited study programmes and institutions are subjects to an assessment process in order to obtain re-accreditation. The maximum capacity of enrolled students is established for each year of studies (one of the financing criteria for State universities).

The external quality assurance evaluation takes into consideration: teaching, student support services, research, employability and the Internal Quality Assurance/management system ^[23].

There are several ongoing strategic projects regarding quality assurance, such as the Romanian Higher Education Improvement Project on University Management and Quality and Leadership in Romanian higher education.

4. Challenges Concerning the Student Population

4.1. Underrepresented Groups

The State grants social scholarships to students from lower socio-economic environments, as well as to orphan students or those coming from foster care ^[24], ^[25]. Study loans for candidates coming from low income families are guaranteed by the state and may cover taxes and life costs during university studies. Free fare on the means of transport can be accessed by institutionalized students.

Also, students coming from high-risk backgrounds or socially marginalized, namely Roma people and high school graduates in the rural areas or small cities (with population less than 10 thousand) may benefit from a number of guaranteed budgeted places ^[26].

Financial aid and accommodation subsidize are offered for students coming from low income backgrounds, those in foster care and Romanian ethnic minorities from abroad.

4.2. Student Fees

Fees payable by home students are according to each HE institution policy; the most common amount is approximately 1000 EUR/ year for first cycle non budgeted places and 2000 EUR/ year for second cycle budgeted places given by Ministry of Education. According to the National Educational Law no 1/2011, for budgeted places there are no fees at all ^[27].

International students’ fees are according to each tertiary institution policy. International students are considered any candidate from the member states of the EU, from the European Economic Space and from the Swiss Confederation may take the admission exam for a public, private or confessional higher education for each educational cycle and program, in the same conditions provided by law for the Romanian citizens ^[28].

4.3. Public Grants and Scholarships

The national education law specifies that public high education system is free, for the amount of students approved by the government, and charged, in the limits of the Law. 25 percentages of first cycle students receives a grant and/or scholarship. Same percentage of students in second cycle receives a grant. Values of grants/scholarships available are: minimum 300 EUR/ year and maximum 1000 EUR/ year, most commonly 300 EUR/year. The non-tax based benefits eligibility criteria are: low income of parents, age of student, disability.

In Romania the public non-cash student support are: subsidized accommodation, subsidized health insurance. Full time students receive accommodation support given by State ^[29], and also receive 50% reduction for public transportation ^[30].

4.4. Student and Staff Mobility

The European Higher Education Area’s (EHEA) hallmark was designed to be the mobility of students, teachers, early stage researchers and staff mobility. Student mobility increased constantly in Europe. 200,000 students per year do part of their studies abroad through the Erasmus Programme and 2.2 million students have been mobile since 1987 (European Students’ Union: Bologna with Student Eyes 2012). According to Eurostat database, 2.1% of EU students participated in mobility in 2000 (1.5% of Romanian students) and 3.1% of EU-27 countries (3.9% of Romanian students) ^[31]. By 2020, at least 20% of those graduating in the EHEA should have had a study or training period abroad (Leuven Communiqué).

Lately, the mobility flows have become a central point of focus, with increasing emphasis on attracting students from outside the EU or EHEA. Significant imbalances in mobility flows between continents, countries, regions and institutions have been stated. Statistics show more outgoing than incoming students (according to the National Institute of Statistics for incoming, OECD data basis/ Eurostat for outgoing students). The mobility flows are most imbalanced with USA, Canada and Western Europe (more outgoing students than incoming) and with Eastern Europe and neighboring countries: more incoming than outgoing ^[32].

The European Ministers have supported the concept of “balanced mobility” in the 2009 Bologna Policy Forum Statement. Therefore, most EU countries pay more attention to balancing the mobility flows. The European strategy for mobility proposed to adopt in the 2012 Bucharest Ministerial Conference needs to be used as a tool to remove the remaining barriers.

The national strategy to foster mobility is materialized in several national policies, regulated by legal acts. Initiatives are focused on financial incentives/scholarships to foster mobility (e.g. scholarships scheme for studies, doctorate and specialization and other forms of support for students having Romanian nationality from neighboring countries or for Romanian diaspora abroad; scholarships scheme for study periods abroad for Romanian undergraduate and graduate students; additional governmental support for Romanian students abroad on the basis of a bilateral or unilateral governmental agreement; scholarships scheme for graduate research or graduate study periods abroad in EU policies area (Ministry of Education/ National Centre for Recognition and Equivalence of Diplomas Granted Abroad). Recognition of periods of study completed at other universities by Romanian students (facilitated by the implementation of the National Qualifications Register), and applying Gravier regarding the access of EU students in Romanian universities, are steps taken towards increasing student mobility, and improving student completion rate.

Results of an inquiry on student and staff mobility ^[33] show some particular geographic regions which are given priority for student and/or staff mobility in the national strategy (Table 5).

Table 5. Priority Regions for student and/or staff mobility

Download as

Veiw figure View Table

The support measures implemented to foster student mobility include special service for international students offered by all Romanian universities which can offer accommodation to foreign students under the same conditions as for Romanian students or have special accommodation facilities for foreign students paying tuition fees.

Table 6. Obstacles to student mobility (most important = 1, second most important = 2, and third most important = 3)

Download as

Veiw figure View Table

The most important obstacles to student mobility addressed in national measures highlighted by the inquiry are: motivation especially for outgoing students, immigration restrictions and language issues for incoming mobility, and recognition of disciplines for outgoing students (Table 6).

The obstacles of staff mobility are the lack of motivation for outgoing mobility, legal issues such as employment arrangements or double taxing for incoming staff, and language issues for both forms of mobility (Table 7).

Table 7. Obstacles to staff mobility (most important = 1, second most important = 2, and third most important= 3)

Download as

Veiw figure View Table