Study on Effect of Defective Ground Structure on Hybrid Microstrip Array Antenna
1Department. of Microwave Lab, PG Studies and Research in Applied Electronics, Gulbarga University, Karnataka, INDIA
This paper presents a novel study on effect of rectangular shape defective ground structure (DGS) implemented on two, four and eight element hybrid microstrip array antenna. The proposed antennas are designed using low cost glass epoxy material. The bandwidth and radiation performance of the antenna is studied and found that as the elements of the antenna are increased, bandwidth also increases by retaining almost the same radiation pattern and gain. Experimentally measured results and design concepts are presented and discussed. These antennas may find application in modern communication system, in radar systems like SAR, monopulse tracking radar and C, X and Ku band microwave applications.
At a glance: Figures
Keywords: DGS, microstrip array antenna, SAR, HPBW, gain, bandwidth
Wireless and Mobile Technologies, 2013 1 (1),
Received December 20, 2012; Revised June 07, 2013; Accepted July 08, 2013Copyright: © 2013 Science and Education Publishing. All Rights Reserved.
Cite this article:
- Mallikarjun, S L, and P M Hadalgi. "Study on Effect of Defective Ground Structure on Hybrid Microstrip Array Antenna." Wireless and Mobile Technologies 1.1 (2013): 1-5.
- Mallikarjun, S. L. , & Hadalgi, P. M. (2013). Study on Effect of Defective Ground Structure on Hybrid Microstrip Array Antenna. Wireless and Mobile Technologies, 1(1), 1-5.
- Mallikarjun, S L, and P M Hadalgi. "Study on Effect of Defective Ground Structure on Hybrid Microstrip Array Antenna." Wireless and Mobile Technologies 1, no. 1 (2013): 1-5.
|Import into BibTeX||Import into EndNote||Import into RefMan||Import into RefWorks|
Wireless communication has been developed widely and rapidly in the modern world during last decades. The future development of the personal communication device will aim to provide image, speech and data communication at anytime and anywhere around the world. So, present time is witnessing a very rapid growth of wireless technology. To increase access, communication terminals must meet the requirements of multi-band or wide band to sufficiently cover the possible operating bands and for broader connectivity. Wireless technologies has also revolutionized in the field of information technology by making use of high speed internet and data transfer ‘wire free’ via mobile gadgets. The existing wireless systems need the antenna structure to cover the various applications with fewer or preferably with a singe antenna.
In satellite and radar communication applications, microstrip antennas have attracted much interest due to their small size, light weight, low cost on mass production, low profile and easy integration with other components. However one difficulty in using microstrip patch antennas is their narrower bandwidth compared to that of other microwave antennas. In general, regular shape patch antennas have been extensively analyzed but these antennas cannot be applied in every application. In addition, simple patch antenna geometries of regular shape in general, resonate only at a single frequency and their bandwidth is also very poor (2 to 3 %). With the recent advancements in satellite and radar communications, the demand for broad band and multi band patch antennas was realized. Looking at inherent properties of patch antennas, these requirements forced workers for modification in patch antenna geometries. For this reason in recent years, there has been a great deal of research on ways to overcome the bandwidth problem of microstrip patch antenna. In application in which increased bandwidth is needed for operation of two or more separate sub-bands, a valid alternative to broadening of the total bandwidth is the use of dual or multi-frequency microstrip antennas .
The other disadvantage is the excitation of surface waves that occurs in the substrate layer. Surface waves are undesired because when a patch antenna radiates, a portion of total available radiated power becomes trapped along the surface of the substrate. It can extract total available power for radiation to space wave. Therefore, surface wave can reduce the antenna efficiency, gain and bandwidth. For arrays, surface waves have a significant impact on the mutual coupling between array elements .
Recently introduction of EBG and defective ground structure (DGS) made a significant break-through in the improvement of microstrip antennas characteristics. DGS is realized by etching the ground plane of microstrip antenna, this disturbs the shield current distribution in the ground plane which influences the input impedance and current flow of the antenna. The geometry of DGS can be one or few etched structures which are simpler and do not need a large area to implement it.
Many shapes of DGS slot have been studied for single element microstrip antenna such as circle, dumbbells and spiral. For two, four and eight element rectangular array a rectangular DGS is studied , however not many have realized it in hybrid antenna arrays.
This paper discusses the influence of rectangle shape DGS towards the improvement of impedance bandwidth and radiation properties. By adding the DGS, the surface wave propagation in the dielectric layer is suppressed, resulting into enhancement in impedance bandwidth by retaining almost the same radiation pattern and gain.
2. Antenna Configuration
The proposed antennas are designed using low cost glass epoxy material having dielectric constant Єr = 4.2 and thickness h = 0.166 cm. The geometry of two element hybrid microstrip array antenna with rectangle shape DGS (THMAA) is shown in Figure 1.
The elements of THMAA is designed for the resonant frequency of 9.4 GHz with dimensions
After analysis, L = 0.66 cm and W = 0.99cm.
The elements of this array antenna are excited through simple corporate feed arrangement. This feed arrangement consist of matching transformer, quarter wave transformer, coupler and power divider for better impedance matching between feed and radiating elements. The microstripline feed is designed by using the W/d ratio equation taking the known value of characteristic impedance Z0 and dielectric constant of substrate material εr. The design equations are,
The length of microstripline is obtained from effective guide wavelength g. It is given by,
The length of microstripline feed Lf = g/4cm is taken in order to keep minimum loss in microstrip line feed.
A two-way power divider made up of 70Ω matching transformer of dimension ML70 = 0.41, MW70 = 0.16cm is used between 100Ω microstrip line of dimension L100 = 0.83, W100 = 0.07cm and 50Ω microstrip line of dimension L50 = 0.41, W50 = 0.31cm. The equations used for designing two-way power divider are,
A coupler of dimension CL = CW = 0.31 cm is used between 50Ω microstrip lines to couple the power. The 50Ω microstrip line is connected at the center of the driven element through a quarter wave transformer of dimension Lt = 0.41, Wt = 0.04 cm for better impedance matching. The impedance of quarter wave transformer is given by
A notch is inserted at the four corners of last radiating element. The dimensions of notch length LN and width WN are taken in terms of λ0. The LN and WN are optimized to λ0/14 (0.22 cm) and λ0/10 (0.33 cm) respectively. This optimized notch is selected, as it is more effective in enhancing the impedance bandwidth.
A rectangular DGS is embedded exactly below all the radiating elements. The dimensions of DGS of length LDGS and width WDGS are taken in terms of λ0. The LDGS and WDGS of the DGS are optimized to λ0/13 (0.0119 cm) and λ0/26 (0.0255 cm) respectively. This optimized DGS is selected, as it is more effective in enhancing the impedance bandwidth .
At the tip of microstrip line feed of 50Ω, a coaxial SMA connector is used for feeding the microwave power. The array elements are kept at a distance of (D = 2.79) cm from their center point. This optimized distance is selected in order to add the radiated power in free space . Further the study is carried out for four element hybrid microstrip array antenna with rectangular DGS (FHMAA) and eight element hybrid microstrip array antenna (EHMAA).
3. Experimental Results
The impedance bandwidths for the proposed antennas are measured at 4 to 18 GHz frequencies. The measurements are taken on Vector Network Analyzer (Rohde & Schwarz, German make ZVK Model No. 1127.8651). The variation of reflection coefficient versus frequency of THMAA, FHMAA and EHMAA are shown in Figure 2.
The impedance bandwidth is calculated by using the equation
where, fH and fL are the higher and lower cut-off frequencies of the band respectively, when its reflection coefficient becomes -10 dB and fc is the center frequency of band.
The experimental impedance bandwidth in term of MHz, percentage and reflection coefficient of all the proposed antennas is tabulated in Table 1.
The X-Y plane co-polar and cross-polar radiation patterns of all the proposed antennas are measured at their resonating frequencies and found that all the antennas show broad side radiation characteristics. Measured side lobe levels, cross polarization levels are tabulated in Table 1. The half power beam width (HPBW) and gain for the proposed antennas is calculated for their resonating frequencies and are also shown in Table 1.
In order to calculate the gain, the power received (Ps) by the pyramidal horn antenna and the power received (Pt) by the antenna under test are measured independently . With the help of experimental data, the gain of antenna under test (GT) in dB is calculated using the formula,
where, Gs is the gain of pyramidal horn antenna.
From the table it is observed that the proposed antennas are resonating for wide band and multiple frequencies. The multi frequency operation of the antenna may find application in modern radars where the system requires operating at more than one frequency bands. Multi frequency patch antennas may avoid the use of different antennas for each operating band, a typical case is that of Syntactic Aperture Radar (SAR). This would reduce weight and surface area, thus improving the possibilities of accommodation under the launcher fairing . The proposed antennas may also be used for X band radar applications . These antennas can also be used in UWB application and for C and X band microwave applications where limited antenna real estate is available. Further from Table 1, it is observed that the antenna FHMAA can be used for X band monopulse tracking radar 
The variation of input impedance of EHMAA is shown in Figure 3. It is seen that the input impedance has multiple loops at the center of Smith chart that validates its wide band and multiple frequency operation.
A new DGS geometry, the rectangle shape have been used for two, four and eight element rectangular microstrip antenna array. The results demonstrate that impedance bandwidth of the antenna is improved by increasing the array elements with DGS. These antennas are more superior as these are fabricated using low cost substrate material. These multi-frequency patch antennas may provide an alternative to large bandwidth planar antennas, in applications in which large bandwidths are needed for operating at two separate transmit-receiver bands. When the two operating frequencies are far apart, a multi-frequency patch structure can be conceived to avoid the use of separate antennas. These antennas are more suitable for modern communication systems and in radar systems like SAR for tracking the target as soon as finding them and for anti-jamming. Further these antennas can be used for X band radar applications, UWB application, for C and X band microwave applications where limited antenna real estate is available and the antenna FHMAA can be used for X band monopulse tracking radar.
We thank to the authorities of Department of Science and Technology (DST), Govt, of India, New Delhi, for sanctioning the FIST Project to the Department of Applied Electronics, Gulbarga University, Gulbarga.
|||K. L. Wong, “Compact and broadband microstrip antennas”, John Wiley & Sons Inc., New York, 2003.|
|||Garg, R., P. Bhartia, I. Bahl and A. Ittipibon, Microstrip Antenna Design Handbook, Artech House, Boston, London, 2001.|
|||S L Mallikarjun, R G Madhuri and P M Hadali, “Effect of rectangular DGS on rectangular microstrip patch array antenna”, Int. Symp. on Microwave and Optical Tech. New Delhi, pp. 257-260, 2009.|
|||S. L. Mallikarjun, P. M. Hadalgi, R. G. Madhuri, and S. A. Malipatil, “Design and Development of Hybrid Microstrip Array Antenna”, The Icfai Journal of Science and Technology, Vol. 5, No. 4, pp.53-62, Dec. 2009.|
|||Constantine Balanies A, Antenna Theory Analysis and Design (John Wiley & Sons Inc.., New York) 1982.|
|||S. Maci and G. Biffi Gentili, “Dual-frequency patch antennas”, IEEE, Trans. Antennas Propagat. Magz., vol. 39, pp. 13-19, Dec. 1997.|
|||X. Qu, S. S. Zhong and Y. M. Zhang, “Dual band dual polarized microstrip antenna array for SAR applications”, Elect. Lett. vol 42, no. 24, pp. 1376-1377, Nov. 2006.|
|||Naveed Ahsan and Jahangir Khan Kayani, “Design of an X-band microstrip monopulse antenna for monopulse tracking radar”, 2nd Int. Bhurban Conf. on Applied Sci and Tech., Bhurban, Pakistan, pp. 313-320, 16-21, 2003.|