Water Quality Assessment of the Coastal Tropical River’Sboubo (Côte d’Ivoire): Physico-Chemical and Biological Aspects
1Laboratoire de Chimie Organique, U.F.R. SSMT, Université Félix HOUPHOUËT-BOIGNY, Côte d’Ivoire.
2Centre Ivoirien Anti-Pollution (C.I.A.POL.), Côte d’Ivoire
3Laboratoire de Botanique, U.F.R. Biosciences, Université Félix HOUPHOUËT-BOIGNY, Côte d’Ivoire.
A study on some physico-chemical and biological variables of water quality was conducted on a coastal river in Ivory Coast. It’s a first assessment on water quality state. Those coastal rivers actually play an important role in the physical, biological and hydrological exchange between lagoons and the sea. Unfortunately, they are not taken into account by the national monitoring for water quality (RNO-CI). The samples were collected along Boubo river body through three stations, in the south of Côte d’Ivoire, during two years. Results show sharp fluctuations of the concentration N-NO3- nitrate, N-NH4+ ammonium and chlorophyll a with more than 20% variation. However, small fluctuations were noted for temperature, pH and conductivity with 4 – 20%. Measures are generally inferior to the threshold for hazardous water class. But respective average concentrations of N-NO3-, P-PO43-, DCO and DBO5 are above natural water threshold, representing 67% of the analyzed samples of P-PO43- and 100% of the other. These results show that the river is not exempt of pollution: 0.2 mg.L-1 of P-PO43- and 0.9 mg.L-1 of N-NO3- are the limit of appropriate siege for the proliferation of invasive aquatic plants (IAP).
At a glance: Figures
Keywords: water quality, nutriments, chlorophyll a, pollution, eutrophication, river, Côte d’Ivoire
Journal of Environment Pollution and Human Health, 2013 1 (2),
Received August 27, 2013; Revised August 28, 2013; Accepted August 29, 2013Copyright: © 2013 Science and Education Publishing. All Rights Reserved.
Cite this article:
- Sébastien, OUFFOUÉ Koffi, et al. "Water Quality Assessment of the Coastal Tropical River’Sboubo (Côte d’Ivoire): Physico-Chemical and Biological Aspects." Journal of Environment Pollution and Human Health 1.2 (2013): 9-15.
- Sébastien, O. K. , Moreto, S. , Yapo, K. D. , Didiomon, S. , Philippe, D. K. , & Félix, T. Z. (2013). Water Quality Assessment of the Coastal Tropical River’Sboubo (Côte d’Ivoire): Physico-Chemical and Biological Aspects. Journal of Environment Pollution and Human Health, 1(2), 9-15.
- Sébastien, OUFFOUÉ Koffi, SALLA Moreto, KICHO Denis Yapo, SORO Didiomon, DA Kouhété Philippe, and TONZIBO Zanahi Félix. "Water Quality Assessment of the Coastal Tropical River’Sboubo (Côte d’Ivoire): Physico-Chemical and Biological Aspects." Journal of Environment Pollution and Human Health 1, no. 2 (2013): 9-15.
|Import into BibTeX||Import into EndNote||Import into RefMan||Import into RefWorks|
Demographic growth in developing countries has brought a fast expansion in urbanization and industrialisation. Côte d’Ivoire, a West African state, possesses a vast hydrographic network, mainly in the southern part. This network is threatened by serious pollutions mainly due to uncontrolled population growth. In 1994, a national monitoring network for water quality was put in place in order to know physico-chemical and ecological quality of waters. The monitoring program has covered 55 fixed stations of water body withdrawal, of sediments and living organisms. 28 stations were counted on inland waterways, 18 stations in Ebrié lagoon of Abidjan Central Basin and 9 stations along the coast from east to west.Actually, this network was focused on three major rivers (Comoé, Bandama, Sassandra) and doesn’t take into account many rivers and water sources which play a key role in economic, social and cultural of population’s life. This situation explains the lack of scientific series and data. In the coastal area they are many rivers which represent nutritive and biodiversity resources. Unfortunately they are under pollution impact. These zones are known for decades for intense agricultural activities (industrial and local plantations of coffee, cocoa, pineapple, palm oil …) and mining. The farm cover nearly 44% of the area of this region . The production of these cultures favorise the use of pesticides and chemical fertilizers. The residues of
chemical products are carried and focused in inland water. It modifies some local waterways quality and leads to deep changes in the composition and structure of animal and vegetable organisms of this hydrosystem .
2. Material and Methods2.1. Sampling Area
Boubo River is among the main coastal rivers of the country (Figure 1). It stretches from Center to the South coast over 130 Km with a catchment area of 5,100 km². Overall, twelve (12) campaigns grouped into four (04) great seasons were realized from May 2009 to April 2010. The campaigns of collect of samples covered the periods of Long Dry Season (LDS), Minor Dry Season (MDS), the Long Wet Season (LWS) and the Minor Wet Season (MWS). Three (03) sampling stations were installed along the stream and heading from upstream to downstream :
• Upstream: Station St1 (station of Divo, 5°75’ N et 5°31’ W) on the deck located on Divo-Lakota route, at 5 km from the downtown.
• In the center: Station St2 (PALMCI-Boubo, 5°61’ N et 5°25’ O) on the bridge located at 400 m from palm oil production unit (PALMCI-Divo).
• Downstream: Station St3 (Station of Adahidougou, 5°18’ N et 5°11’ W), on the bridge, 25 km to Grand-Lahou town.
The parameters studied are temperature, pH, conductivity, transparency, nitrates N-NO3-, ammonium N-NH4+, orthophosphates, Biological Oxygen Demand (BOD5), Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) and chlorophyll a.
2.2.1. Physical Parameters Measurement
The pH, conductivity (µS.cm-1 ) and water temperature (T°C) are measured in situ with calibrated multiparameters probe. The transparency of water (m) is measured using Secchi disc.
2.1.2. Chemical Parameters Analysis
• The nutrients, mg.L-1,(N-NO3-, N-NH4+ and P-PO43-) are analyzed at the laboratory. The concentrations determined by  calorimetric method for nitrates and method for orthophosphates . The nitrate concentrations are determined by difference, once they are reduced into nitrites on a Cd-Cu column that enables nitrites analyzed. The concentration of nitrate is determined by difference of the initial nitrites concentration in the sample. Orthophosphate is determined as follow: with antimonies, ammonium molybdate form a complex with orthophosphates; that complex is reducible by ascorbic acid. The blue coloration reduced form, absorbs wavelength at 885nm, helping to know ion phosphate concentration in the dosed sample. After the value solution, vessel sample is placed in the spectrophotometer to see ion content.
• Chemical Oxygen Demand, mg.L-1, (COD): a V1 volume of water is treated in a test tube containing a specific COD reagent. They are all placed in a digester under 120°C during 2 hours. We let the mixture cool down and then we measure with the help of the spectrophotometer that gives a concentration (mg/l) corresponding to the DCO value. The BOD5, mg.L-1 (Biological Oxygen Demand): a V2 volume of water sample is poured into an oxi-top glass flask (1 liter colored flask). The flask is clogged by a closure with a digital display for DBO5 reading. The flask is then placed into an incubator for 5 days. At the 5th day, we proceed to the reading of DBO5 value on the screen (mg.L-1).2.3. Chlorophyll a Analysis
Chlorophyll a dosage is done using NFT90-117 method. A volume of 250 ml is filtered through GF/C ruled filter paper. The filtrate is placed into a tube containing 90 degree ethanol. Then we move to the centrifugation at 3,000 r.p.m for 15 minutes. The organics phase is used to measure chlorophyll with calibrated spectrophotometer .
3. Results3.1. Quantitative Analysis of Variables (Table 1 a,b and Figure 2a)
• Temperature: extreme values are measured at St2 : Boubo River, center, during Major Dry Season (MDS) between 24 and 25.8° C with an average of 25.82°C.
• PH: values of water are between 5.8 and 7.3 with an average of 6.53. Minimal value is obtained at Station St2 during Long Dry Season (MDS).
• Conductivity: values are between 88 and 160.7 µS.cm-1 with an average of 117,91 µS.cm-1. The low values are obtained at Station St2 during the Minor Wet Season (MWS). The maximal conductivity is measured during the Minor Dry Season (MDS).
• Transparency: water transparency is measured between 0.2 and 0.9 with an average of 0.62 m. the lowest measure was determined at Adahidougou Station (St3), downstream during the Long Wet Season (LWS).
• Nitrate (N-NO3-): nitrate concentration is between 0.44 and 2.2 mg.L-1. The average value is of 0.94 0.94 mg.L-1. The lowest nitrate concentration was measured at Station St2, Center in Long Dry Season (LDS). The highest value has been obtained at Adahidougou Station (St3), during Long Wet Season (LWS).
• Ammonium (N-NH4+): ammonium concentration varies between 0.01 and 0.04 mg.L-1. The average is of 0.02 mg.L-1. The lowest values are measured downstream (St1) and in the Center (St2) during Long Dry Season (LDS). The highest content in stations is measured St1 and St3 during Minor Wet Season (MWS).
• Orthophosphates (P-PO43-): orthophosphates vary between 0.1 and 0.5 mg.L-1 with an average concentration of 0.21 mg.L-1. The lowest concentration is measured at station St1 downstream the river with during Minor Dry Season (MDS) and the Minor Wet Season (MWS). Highest concentrations are noted during Long Wet Season (LWS).
• Biological Oxygen Demand BOD5 and COD extreme values vary respectively between 14 and 44 mg.L-1 and 44 and 116 mg.L-1 with averages of 29.17 mg.L-1 and 77.33 mg.L-1. Lowest contents in BOD5 and COD are determined at station St3, upstream, during Long Wet Season (LWS) and highest value at Station St3 during Minor Wet Season (MWS).
• Chlorophyll a: The concentrations for Boubo river water vary between 7.6 and 27.1 mg.L-1. The averages of chlorophyll a value for these waters are 14.62 mg.L-1. The lowest chlorophyll is determined at station St1, during Minor Dry Season (MDS) and the highest at station St3, during Minor Wet Season (MWS).
We generally notice a fluctuation of the different variable measurement from one station to another and from season to another (Table 2). The importance of this fluctuation is evaluated with the Ratio of the standard deviation and the average. It appears, along the rivers, strong fluctuations of concentration of nutriments N-NO3-, N-NH4+, P-PO43- and chlorophyll a with more than 20%. Low fluctuations are determined for the temperature, pH and conductivity with 4-20%.
4. Discussion4.1. Seasonal and Spatial Variation
The study shows that extreme temperatures in PALMCI-BOUBO station (St2) located in the Center (Figure 2b). The average temperature calculated 25.71°C on most of the stations is between 25-29°C like most of tropical rivers in Côte d’Ivoire [2, 5] and estuarial water rivers in France . Differences in temperature of the water in the tropical zone are relatively low in comparison to those of temperate countries. A very large rise in temperature is caused by the intrusion of hot water of industrial liquid effluents. The St2 station, which is located in the area of the production palm oil, is not affected by the warm waters of these effluents. This situation can be explained by the fact that the temperature drop as far as we move away from the point of discharge. Water found the average surrounding equilibrium temperature. Temperature is an important factor in the development of phytoplankton. Authors have noticed that an increase of the water temperature would facilitate chemical reactions with the mineralization of organic matter into nutrients. The increase in temperature reduces the solubility of the gases dissolved in the water. Authors have shown that an increase of 7°C causes a fall of 13% O2. An elevated temperature promotes the degradation of matter organic in oxidation. Extreme measures of the BOD5 and COD vary respectively between 17 and 44 mg.L-1 43 and 116 mg.L-1. These results show the presence of organic matter naturally and quickly biodegradable in equilibrium with little degradable organic matter. The organic matter with little degradable matter is an index of chemical contamination. The mineralization of organic matter into nutrients (N-NH4+, N-NO3-, and P-PO43-), sunlight and permanent oxygenation through the movement of water, create favorable conditions for the development of phytoplankton.
The river Boubo presents in average, low acid PH 6.5. The extreme values are obtained during the Long Dry Season (5.8) and the Minor Dry Season (7.3). These values are comparable to the pH generally measured from coastal rivers between 6.4 and 7.5. The tendency to the acidity of the waters of the Boubo’s river would be justified by the localization in coastal zone. In according to Iltis & Lévêque’s studies in 1982, coastal rivers have a slightly acidic and alkaline pH . Also it had been showed that the weakly acidic or slightly alkaline waters are favorable to the development of many Desmidiales [5, 8]. When the values of pH are between 6.4 – 8, the nutrients are in their ionic and dissolved forms. Thus ammoniac nitrogen is in ionic form dissolves (NH4+) non-toxic, favorable to the development of algae. There is also the phosphorus as P-PO43-..Generally, the average value of the conductivity is 117.92 µS.cm-1 in the unpolluted water. The extreme values obtained (58.7 and 140. 8 µS. cm-1) are close to those studies on the water quality of coastal rivers of Côte d’Ivoire [9, 10]. These values are found generally in natural and unpolluted water. These results are confirmed by previous work that showed a range of conductivity between 100 and 200 µS.cm-1 in the tropical region in coastal streams and are influenced by continental waters .
In temperate zone, ANDRESEN LEITÃO in 1984 proposed a scale of 444 µS.cm-1. This value corresponds to the limit of mineralization . In comparaison, the results of conductivity obtained, show that the river’s Boubo is weakly mineralized. The respective averages of nutrients are 0.94 mg.L-1 for the N-NO3-, 0.024 mg.L-1 N-NH4+ and 0.21 mg.L-1 P-PO43-. The highest concentrations reach 2.2 mg.L-1 N-NO3- and 0.5 mg.L for the P-PO43- respectively at the station of the Centre (St2) and downstream St3 Long Dry Season (LDS). Similar studies have measured concentrations of N-NO3- (0.25 mg.L-1) in the waters of the river Marahoué, located on the Center of the Côte d'Ivoire, and on rivers in general levels of 0.030 mg.L-1 for phosphorus .
In natural waters, nitrogen and phosphorus are naturally present. The respective levels are lower than 0.1 mg/l for the both N-NO3- and N-NH4+ and 0.1 mg.L-1 for the P-PO43-. As the results there is a relative high levels concentration of nutrients in Boubo‘s river during the periods of Long Dry Season (LDS). Naturally the decomposition organics matters from plant and animal produce minerals. There is the high contribution of the charcoal production and the bushfire. This zone is characterized by the importance of agricultural farm of Hevea, palmist oil, cocoa and coffee. There is also a high density of populations using fertilizers and detergents. Domestic waste water containing the detergent agro industrial effluents and fertilizer runoff elevate the nutrient level. The Chlorophyll a is the most prevalent pigment in different micro-algal classes identified in this study. Its quantification allows the determination of algal biomass in waters body. The weakness of chlorophyll a in our results can be explained by the occupation of the water’s surfaces of the stations affected by the aquatic plants such as Eichhornia crassipes, Salvinia molesta and Echinochloa pyramidalis in the dry season. These invasive plants reduce the photosynthesis, hence the low chlorophyll a. The values of chlorophyll obtained, ranging from 9.28 and 14.63 mg.L-1, reflect a wealth of micro-algal biomass through a chlorophyll activity relatively dense. The high concentrations observed during the rainy seasons, especially in stations downstream and in the Centre are similar to the results of PAGES and al. in 1979 . For these authors, the strong values of chlorophyll a are measured at the beginning of the Long Wet Season rainy (GSP). High chlorophyll a concentrations indicate in generally high phytoplankton biomass. These levels of chlorophyll a could explain the abundance of the Chlorophyta, the Heterocontophyta, the Cyanophyta and Euglenophyta .
The water quality class is defined by many de references: p.ex WHO, European Directives, EPA or the using and constraints of the national water regulations (Table 2). In absence of official references for watersheds in Côte d'Ivoire, the variables of this studied are used. The mean and extreme values had been compared with the data in the literature on the quality waters . The Table 3 summaries the value of the limit in natural water and the threshold of the exposure to pollution. Most of measures are significantly lower than the classified waters polluted. However, as the result, it appears that the average of N-NO3-, P-PO43-, COD and BOD5 are superior than the threshold values established for natural waters. That represents 67% of samples analyzed for the P-PO43- and 100% for the other. These results show that the river cannot be considered unpolluted. The level measured at 0.2 mg.L-1 and 0.92 mg.L-1 for P-PO43- indicate the presence of pollution and the tendency for eutrophication and proliferation of invasive aquatic plants. The fringe of Eichhornia crassipes, Salvinia molesta and Echinochloa pyramidalis is a physical indication of the phenomena.
Table 2. Comparison table of the measured average values and levels of quality of waters according to Deborah
The study is based on the parameters: temperature, pH, conductivity, transparency, nitrates N-NO3-, ammonium N-NH4+, orthophosphate P-PO43-, the Biological Demand in Oxygen (BOD5), Chemical Demand Oxygen (DCO) and the chlorophyll a. Indicators of the quality of a water body. The results show that temperature, pH and transparency are normal like National River. It appear in the same order of magnitude than surface water non-exposed to pollution. However the BOD5, COD and nutrient are both high levels. It indicates the beginning of eutrophication. Chlorophyll a concentration is significant by the presence of invasive aquatic plants. The main sources of contributions are domestic rural waste, agro-industrial holdings and bush fires. This studies have shown that hydrophytes colonizing water lagoon of Abidjan caused by the rivers. Also that the nutrients (N and P) present in the washed water were the major factor. ONO River, located in the Southeast, whose watershed was more contaminated by residues of fertilizers (NPK), is principal sources of proliferation of the AIP. These first results highlight the fragility of river Boubo like the most of coastal rivers and the risk of pollution by nutrients from anthropogenic activities. In the long term this river may be transformed into a site of high production of IAP. This situation will a change the physico-chemical, biological and hydrological equilibrium. That why it urgent to take rigorousness actions to limit the charge of nutrients and implement the national program for the integrated management of water resources.
The authors would like to thank AIEA projects RAF 7 /008 and RAF 7 /009: Supporting an Integrated Approach for Marine Pollution Monitoring Using Nuclear Analytical Techniques for providing financial and technical support for this research.
|||ANONYME, 2001. Recensement National de l’Agriculture (RNA) 2001. Région du Sud-Comoé. Ministère d’État, Ministère de l’Agriculture. Direction des statistiques, de la documentation et de l’informatique de Côte d’Ivoire, 29 p.|
|||NIAMIEN-ÉBROTTIÉ J.E. 2010. Composition et distribution spatio-temporelle des peuplements d’algues de quatre rivières du Sud-Est de la Côte d’Ivoire (Soumié, Éholié, Éhania et Noé). Thèse de Doctorat Unique, Université d’Abobo-Adjamé, Abidjan, Côte d’Ivoire, 146 p.|
|||AMINOT A. & CHAUSSEPIED M., 1983. Manuel des analyses chimiques en milieu marin. CNEXO, Éditions Jouve, Paris, France, 395 p.|
|||MURPHY, J. & RILEY, J.P. 1962. A modified single solution method for the determination of phosphorus in natural waters. Anal. chemica acta, 12, 31-36.|
|||DA K.P., 2007. Étude taxinomique du phytoplancton dulçaquicole des masses d’eau lentiques et lotiques de quelques sites au Sud de la Côte d’Ivoire, entre les fleuves Bandama et Bia : apports de la microscopie électronique à balayage. Thèse d’État ès Sciences Naturelles, Université de Cocody, Abidjan, Côte d’Ivoire, 402 p.|
|||DE OLIVEIRA C.J., 2000. Le phytoplancton estuarien de deux fleuves de Guyane française (l’Iracoubo et le Sinnamary) : caractérisation du milieu, composition et diversité spécifique. Thèse de Doctorat de l’Université Paris 6, Paris, France, 258 p.|
|||ILTIS A. & LÉVÊQUE C., 1982. Caractéristiques physico-chimiques des rivières de Côte d’Ivoire. Revue d’Hydrobiologie tropicale, 15 (2) : 115-130.|
|||BREMOND R. & VUICHARD R., 1973. Paramètres de la qualité des eaux. Documentation Française, Paris, France, 178 p.|
|||DIOMANDÉ D., 2001. Macrofaune benthique et stratégies alimentaires de Synodontis bastiani et S. schall en milieu fluvio-lacustre (Bassins Bia et Agnébi, Côte d’Ivoire). Thèse de Doctorat, Université d’Abobo-Adjamé, Abidjan, 260 p.|
|||DIETOA Y. M., 2002. Entomofaune et stratégies alimentaires des poissons du genre Brycinus (Characidae) en milieux fluviatiles et lacustre (Bassins Bia et Agnéby, Côte d’Ivoire). Thèse de Doctorat, Université d’Abobo-Adjamé, Abidjan, 261 p.|
|||SIAKA BARTHÉLÉMY BAMBA, SÉBASTIEN OUFFOUE, MÉLÉCONY C. BLE, SORO BERNARD METONGO & SOULEYMANE BAKAYOKO. 2008. Etat de l’environnement lagunaire de l’ile vitre (grand-bassam, cote d’ivoire) : aspects physiques, chimiques et biologiques Rev. Ivoir. Sci. Technol., 12 : 77-92.|
|||ANDRESEN LEITAO A., 1984. Aspects du phytoplancton d’un bassin de rétention : relations avec quelques paramètres physico-chimiques du milieu. Thèse de Doctorat 3è cycle. Toxicologie. Université Paris V, France, 165 p.|
|||MAINSTONE C.P. & PARR W., 2002. Phosphorus in Rivers - Ecology and Management. The Science of the Total Environment, 282-283 : 25-47.|
|||PAGÈS J., LEMASSON L. & DUFOUR P., 1979. Éléments nutritifs et production primaire dans les lagunes de Côte d’Ivoire : cycle annuel. Arch. Scient. Centre de Rech. Océanogr. Abidjan, 5 (1) : 1-60.|
|||MORETO SALLA, PHILIPPE DA KOUHETE, SEBASTIEN OUFFOUE. 2011. Cyanobactéries des rivières Boubo et Mé dans le Sud côtier de la Côte d’Ivoire Int. J. Biol. Chem. Sci. 5(4): 1365-1373.|
|||DEBORAH CHAPMAN. 1992. DEBORAH CHAPMAN. 1992. Water quality assessment: A guide to the use of biota, sediment and water in environmental monitoring, First edition 585p.|