Research Article
Open Access Peer-reviewed

The Contradictions in Poynting Theorem and Classical Electromagnetic Field Theory

Shuang-ren Zhao
Mutualenergy.org, London, Canada
International Journal of Physics. 2022, 10(5), 242-251. DOI: 10.12691/ijp-10-5-1
Received October 05, 2022; Revised November 11, 2022; Accepted November 20, 2022

Abstract

When studying the energy principle of N current elements, the author found that the Poynting’s theorem of N current elements is very similar to the principle of mutual energy, except that the subscript of the summation symbol is different. Because the mutual energy principle of N current elements and Poynting’s law of N current elements are all energy conservation laws, the author considers that they should be the same. Due to this consideration, the author found that the self-energy flow should not transfer energy. Self-energy flow is the energy flow corresponding to the Poynting vector of a current element, but this energy flow is not zero for any antenna. The author believes that this is a loophole in classical electromagnetic theory. The author’s previous solution was to add a time-reversal wave to Maxwell’s theory. This paper studies this problem through the electromagnetic field of plane-sheet current. It is found that the magnetic field calculated by Maxwell’s equations is still the magnetic field generated by the current itself, but the electric field calculated by Maxwell’s equation is actually the advanced wave generated by the environment of the current.

Keywords:

Maxwell equation, reciprocity theorem, conservation of energy, Poynting theorem, energy flow, transformer, primary coil, secondary coil, transmitting antenna, receiving antenna, retarded wave, retarded potential, advanced wave, advanced potential, absorber, emitter, photons, quantum, electromagnetic wave, electromagnetic field, electromagnetics
[1]  Shuang ren Zhao. The application of mutual energy theorem in expansion of radiation fields in spherical waves. ACTA Electronica Sinica, P.R. of China, 15(3): 88-93, 1987.
 
[2]  Shuangren Zhao. The application of mutual energy formula in expansion of plane waves. Journal of Electronics, P. R. China, 11(2): 204-208, March 1989.
 
[3]  Shuangren Zhao. The simplification of formulas of electromagnetic fields by using mutual energy formula. Journal of Electronics, P.R. of China, 11(1):73-77, January 1989.
 
[4]  Adrianus T. de Hoop. Time-domain reciprocity theorems for electromagnetic fields in dispersive media. Radio Science, 22(7): 1171-1178, December 1987.View Article
 
[5]  V.H. Rumsey. A short way of solving advanced problems in electromagnetic fields and other linear systems. IEEE Transactions on antennas and Propagation, 11(1): 73-86, January 1963.View Article
 
[6]  W. J. Welch. Reciprocity theorems for electromagnetic fields whose time dependence is arbitrary. IRE trans. On Antennas and Propagation, 8(1): 68-73, January 1960.View Article
 
[7]  Shuang ren Zhao. A new interpretation of quantum physics: Mutual energy flow interpretation. American Journal of Modern Physics and Application, 4(3): 12-23, 2017.
 
[8]  Shuang ren Zhao. Photon can be described as the normalized mutual energy flow. Journal of Modern Physics, 11(5): 668-682, 2020.View Article
 
[9]  Shuang ren Zhao. A solution for wave-particle duality using the mutual energy principle corresponding to schroedinger equation. Physics Tomorrow Letters, 2020.
 
[10]  Shuang ren Zhao. Huygens principle based on mutual energy flow theorem and the comparison to the path integral. Physics Tomorrow Letters, pages 09–06, JANUARY 2021.
 
[11]  Shuang ren Zhao. Photon models are derived by solving a bug in poynting and maxwell theory, 2017.
 
[12]  Shuang ren Zhao. Mutual stress flow theorem of electromagnetic field and extension of newton’s third law. Theoretical Physics Letters, 10(7), 2022.
 
[13]  Shuang ren Zhao. The paradox that induced electric field has energy in maxwell theory of classical electromagnetic field is shown and solved. Iternational Journal of Physics, 10(4): 204-217, 2022.View Article
 
[14]  Shuang ren Zhao. Solve the maxwell’s equations and schrodinger’s equation but avoiding the sommerfeld radiation condition. Theoretical Physics Letters, 10(5), 2022.
 
[15]  Shuang ren Zhao. The theory of mutual energy flow proves that macroscopic electromagnetic waves are composed of photons. Iternational Journal of Physics, 10(5), 2022.
 
[16]  Shuang ren Zhao. Review of the advanced waves inside the transformer, antenna and photon system. Theoretical Physics Letters.
 
[17]  Wheeler. J. A. and Feynman. R. P. Rev. Mod. Phys., 17: 157, 1945.View Article
 
[18]  Wheeler. J. A. and Feynman. R. P. Rev. Mod. Phys., 21: 425, 1949.View Article
 
[19]  J. H. Poynting. On the transfer of energy in the electromagnetic field. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, 175: 343-361, JANUARY 1884.View Article
 
[20]  John Cramer. The transactional interpretation of quantum mechanics. Reviews of Modern Physics, 58: 647-688, 1986.View Article
 
[21]  John Cramer. An overview of the transactional interpretation. International Journal of Theoretical Physics, 27: 227, 1988.View Article