## About Coefficients and Order of Convergence of the Optimal Quadrature Formula

**Aziz K. Boltaev**^{1}, **Abdullo R. Hayotov**^{1,}, **Kholmat M. Shadimetov**^{1}

^{1}Department of Computational Methods, Institute of Mathematics, National University of Uzbekistan, Do`rmon yo`li str. Tashkent, Uzbekistan

2. The Extremal Function and Representation of the Error Functional

3. The System for Coefficients of The Optimal Quadrature Formula

4. Coefficients of Optimal Quadrature Formula in the Sense of Sard

5. The Norm of the Error Functional of the Optimal Quadrature Formula in the Sense of Sard

### Abstract

In this paper we construct an optimal quadrature formula in the sense of Sard in the Hilbert space K_{2}(P_{3}). Using S.L. Sobolev's method we obtain new optimal quadrature formula and give explicit expressions for the corresponding optimal coefficients. Furthermore, we investigate order of convergence of the optimal formula. The obtained optimal quadrature formula is exact for the functions e^{-x}, .

**Keywords:** optimal quadrature formulas, error functional, extremal function, hilbert space, optimal coefficients

*American Journal of Numerical Analysis*, 2014 2 (2),
pp 35-48.

DOI: 10.12691/ajna-2-2-2

Received December 11, 2013; Revised February 16, 2014; Accepted February 24, 2014

**Copyright**© 2014 Science and Education Publishing. All Rights Reserved.

### Cite this article:

- Boltaev, Aziz K., Abdullo R. Hayotov, and Kholmat M. Shadimetov. "About Coefficients and Order of Convergence of the Optimal Quadrature Formula."
*American Journal of Numerical Analysis*2.2 (2014): 35-48.

- Boltaev, A. K. , Hayotov, A. R. , & Shadimetov, K. M. (2014). About Coefficients and Order of Convergence of the Optimal Quadrature Formula.
*American Journal of Numerical Analysis*,*2*(2), 35-48.

- Boltaev, Aziz K., Abdullo R. Hayotov, and Kholmat M. Shadimetov. "About Coefficients and Order of Convergence of the Optimal Quadrature Formula."
*American Journal of Numerical Analysis*2, no. 2 (2014): 35-48.

Import into BibTeX | Import into EndNote | Import into RefMan | Import into RefWorks |

### 1. Introduction

We consider the following quadrature formula

(1.1) |

with an error functional given by

(1.2) |

where *C*_{β} and are coefficients and nodes of the formula (1), respectively, *x[0,1](x)* is the characteristic function of the interval , and is Dirac's delta-function. We suppose that the functions belong to the Hilbert space

equipped with the norm

(1.3) |

where

The equality (1.3) is semi-norm and if and only if

where *d*_{1}, *d*_{2} and *d*_{3} are constants.

In order that the error functional (1.2) is defined on the space it is necessary to impose the following conditions

(1.4) |

The equalities (1.4) mean that our quadrature formula will be exact for functions , and .

It should be noted that for a linear differential operator of order *n*, *L*≡*P*_{n}*(d/dx)*, Ahlberg, Nilson, and Walsh in the book [1^{[1]}, Chapter 6] investigated the Hilbert spaces in the context of generalized splines. Namely, with the inner product

is a Hilbert space if we identify functions that differ by a solution of . Also, such a type of spaces of periodic functions and optimal quadrature formulae were discussed in ^{[8]}.

The corresponding error of the quadrature formula (1.1) can be expressed in the form

(1.5) |

and it is a linear functional in the conjugate space to the space .

By the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality

the error (1.5) can be estimated by the norm of the error functional (1.2), i.e.,

In this way, the error estimate of the quadrature formula (1.1) on the space can be reduced to finding a norm of the error functional in the conjugate space .

Obviously this norm of the error functional depends on the coefficients and the nodes , . The problem of finding the minimal norm of the error functional with respect to coefficients and nodes is called as Nikol'skii problem, and the obtained formula is called the optimal quadrature formula in the sense of Nikol'skii. This problem first considered by S.M. Nikol'skii ^{[16]}, and continued by many authors (see e.g. ^{[3, 6, 7, 8, 17, 36]} and references therein). A minimization of the norm of the error functional with respect only to coefficients , when nodes are fixed, is called as Sard's problem. The obtained formula is called the optimal quadrature formula in the sense of Sard. This problem was first investigated by A. Sard ^{[19]}.

There are several methods of construction of optimal quadrature formulas in the sense of Sard (see e.g. ^{[3, 30]}). In the space , based on these methods, Sard's problem was investigated by many authors (see, for example, [2,3,7,9-15,20,21,23,26-35] and references therein). Here, is the Sobolev space of functions, with a square integrable -th generalized derivative.

It should be noted that a construction of optimal quadrature formulas in the sense of Sard, which are exact for solutions of linear differential equations, was given in ^{[11, 14]}, using the Peano kernel method, including several examples for some number of nodes.

Optimal quadrature formulas in the sense of Sard were constructed in ^{[12, 24, 25]}, using Sobolev's method in the spaces and . Recently in the work ^{[37]} in space the optimal quadrature formula was obtained for the Cauchy type singular integrals.

In this paper we give the solution of Sard's problem in the space , using Sobolev's method for an arbitrary number of nodes . Namely, we find the coefficients (and the error functional ) such that

(1.6) |

Thus, in order to construct an optimal quadrature formula in the sense of Sard in , we need to solve the following problems:

**Problem 1.** Calculate the norm of the error functional for the given quadrature formula (1.1).

**Problem 2.** Find the coefficients Cβ such that the equality (1.6) be satisfied with fixed nodes Xβ.

The rest of the paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 we determine the extremal function which corresponds to the error functional and give a representation of the norm of the error functional (1.2). Section 3 is devoted to a minimization of with respect to the coefficients . We obtain a system of linear equations for the coefficients of the optimal quadrature formula in the sense of Sard in the space . Moreover, the existence and uniqueness of the corresponding solution is proved. Explicit formulas for coefficients of the optimal quadrature formula of the form (1.1) are found in Section 4. In Section 5 we calculate the norm of the error functional (1.2) of the optimal quadrature formula (1.1) and we give some numerical results.

### 2. The Extremal Function and Representation of the Error Functional

In order to solve Problem 1, i.e., to calculate the norm of the error functional (1.2) in the space , we use a concept of the extremal function for a given functional. The function is called the extremal for the functional (cf. ^{[31]}) if the following equality is fulfilled

(2.1) |

Since is a Hilbert space, the extremal function in this space can be found using the Riesz theorem about general form of a linear continuous functional on Hilbert spaces. Then, for the functional and for any there exists such a function , for which the following equality

(2.2) |

holds, where

(2.3) |

is an inner product defined on the space .

Further, we will investigate the solution of the equation (2.2).

Let first , where is a space of infinity-differentiable and finite functions in the interval . Then from (2.3), an integration by parts gives

(2.4) |

According to (2.2) and (2.4) we conclude that

(2.5) |

Thus, when the extremal function is a solution of the equation (2.5). But, we have to find the solution of (2.2) when .

Since the space is dense in , then functions from can be uniformly approximated as closely as desired by functions from the space . For we consider the inner product . Now, an integration by parts gives

Hence, taking into account arbitrariness and uniqueness of the function up to functions , and , taking into account (2.5), it must be fulfilled the following equation

with boundary conditions

(2.6) |

(2.7) |

(2.8) |

Thus, we conclude, that the extremal function is a solution of the boundary value problem (2.5)-(2.8).

Taking the convolution of two functions and , i.e. ,

(2.9) |

we can state the following result which obtained in ^{[4]}.

**Theorem 2.1. **

The solution of the boundary value problem (2.5)-(2.8) is the extremal function of the error functional and it has the following form

where , and are arbitrary real numbers, and

(2.10) |

Now, using Theorem 2.1, we immediately obtain a representation of the norm of the error functional

(2.11) |

Thus, Problem 1 is solved. Further in Sections 3 and 4 we deal with Problem 2.

### 3. The System for Coefficients of The Optimal Quadrature Formula

Let the nodes of the quadrature formula (1.1) be fixed. The error functional (1.2) satisfies the conditions (1.4). Norm of the error functional is a multidimensional function of the coefficients . For finding its minimum under the conditions (1.4), we apply the Lagrange method. Namely, we consider the function

and its partial derivatives equating to zero, so that we obtain the following system of linear equations

(3.1) |

(3.2) |

where is determined by (2.10) and

The system (3.1)-(3.2) has the unique solution and it gives the minimum to under the conditions (3.2) (see ^{[5]}).

Thus at fixed values of the nodes , , the norm of the error functional has the unique minimum for some concrete values of , . As we mentioned in the first section, the quadrature formula with such coefficients is called the optimal quadrature formula in the sense of Sard, and , , are the optimal coefficients. In the sequel, for convenience the optimal coefficients will be denoted as .

### 4. Coefficients of Optimal Quadrature Formula in the Sense of Sard

In this section we solve the system (3.1)-(3.2) and find an explicit formula for the coefficients . We use a similar method, offered by Sobolev ^{[30]} for finding optimal coefficients in the space . Here, we mainly use a concept of functions of a discrete argument and the corresponding operations (see ^{[31]} and ^{[32]}). For completeness we give some of definitions.

Let nodes are equal spaced, i.e., , . Assume that and are real-valued functions defined on the real line .

**Definition 4.1****.**** **

The function is a function of discrete argument if it is given on some set of integer values of .

**Definition 4.2****.**** **

The inner product of two discrete functions and is given by

if the series on right hand side converges absolutely.

**Definition 4.3****.**** **

The convolution of two functions and is the inner product

Suppose that when and . Using these definitions, the system (??)-(2) can be rewritten in the convolution form

(4.1) |

(4.2) |

where

(4.3) |

Now, we consider the following problem:

**Problem A.** For a given find a discrete function *C*β and unknown coefficients , which satisfy the system (4.1)-(4.2).

Further, instead of *C*β we introduce the functions *u**(h*β*)* and *v**(h*β*)* as

In such a statement it is necessary to express *C*β by the function *u**(h*β*)*. For this we have to construct such an operator *D(h*β*)**,* which satisfies the equation

(4.4) |

where δ*(h*β*)* is equal to when β*=0* and is equal to when β*=0*, i.e., δ*(h*β*)* is a discrete delta-function.

In connection with this, a discrete analogue *D(h*β*)* of the differential operator d^{6}/dx^{6}-1, which satisfies (4.4) was constructed in ^{[22]} and some properties were investigated.

Following ^{[22]} we have:

Theorem 4.1. The discrete analogue of the differential operator satisfying the equation (4.4) has the form

(4.5) |

where

are zeros of the polynomial

(4.6) |

and

here

is the polynomial of degree 4, is a small parameter.

**Theorem 4.2. **

The discrete analogue *D(h*β*)* of the differential operator satisfies the following equalities:

Here is the function of discrete argument, corresponding to the function defined by (2.10), and is the discrete delta-function.

Then, taking into account (4.4) and Theorems 4.1 and 4.2, for optimal coefficients we have

(4.7) |

Thus, if we find the function , then the optimal coefficients can be obtained from (4.7). In order to calculate the convolution (4.7) we need a representation of the function for all integer values of . According to (4.1) we get that when . Now, we need a representation of the function when and .

Since for , then , . Now, we calculate the convolution when .

Let , then, taking into account equalities (10) and (2), we have

Denoting

we get for

and for

Now, setting

we formulate the following problem:

**Problem B.** Find the solution of the equation

(4.8) |

in the form

(4.9) |

where *d*_{1}^{-}, *d*_{2}^{-}, *d*_{3}^{-}, *d*_{1}^{+}, *d*_{2}^{+}, *d*_{3}^{+} are unknown coefficients.

It is clear that

These unknowns *d*_{1}^{-}, *d*_{2}^{-}, *d*_{3}^{-}, *d*_{1}^{+}, *d*_{2}^{+}, *d*_{3}^{+} can be found from the equation (4.8), using the function *D(h*β*)*. Then, the explicit form of the function *u(h*β*)* and optimal coefficients *C*β can be obtained. Thus, in this way Problem B, as well as Problem A, can be solved.

However, instead of this, using *D(h*β*)* and *u(h*β*)* and taking into account (4.7), we find here expressions for the optimal coefficients *C*β, β*=1,**…**,N-1*. For this purpose we introduce the following notations

The series in the previous expressions are convergent, because .

Now we have the following.

**Theorem 4.3. **

The coefficients of optimal quadrature formulas in the sense of Sard of the form (1.1) in the space have the following representation

(4.10) |

where and are defined above,

(4.11) |

and are given in Theorem 4.1.

Proof. Let . Then from (4.7), using (4.5) and (4.9), we have

Hence, taking into account the previous notations, we get

(4.12) |

Now, using Theorems 4.1 and 4.2 and equality (4.3), we calculate the convolution . Namely,

Substituting this convolution into (4.12), taking into account (4.11) we obtain (4.10), and Theorem 4.3 is proved.

According Theorem 4.3 it is clear, that in order to obtain the exact expressions of the optimal coefficients we need only and , . They can be found from an identity with respect to , which can be obtained by substituting the equality (4.10) into (4.1). Namely, equating the corresponding coefficients the left and the right hand sides of the equation (4.1) we find and . The coefficients and follow directly from (4.2).

Finally, we can formulate and prove the following result:

**Theorem 4.4. **

The coefficients of the optimal quadrature formulas in the sense of Sard of the form in the space are

where is defined by (4.11) and are given in Theorem 4.1 and .

Proof. First from equations (4.2) we have

Hence, using (4.10), after some simplifications we get

(4.13) |

(4.14) |

Further, we consider the convolution *G(h*β*)*C*β in equation (4.1), i.e.,

(4.15) |

where

and

Using (4.10), after some calculations and simplifications can be reduced to the following form

where we used the fact that are zeros of the polynomial defined by (4.6).

Also, keeping in mind (4.2), for we get the following expression

Now, substituting (4.15) into equation (4.1) we get the following identity with respect to

(4.16) |

where is defined by (4.3).

Unknowns in (4.16) are , , , , , and . Equating the corresponding coefficients of , and of both sides of the identity (4.16), for unknowns , , and we get the following system of linear equations

where

The coefficients , and can be found also from (15) by equating the corresponding coefficients of , and . In this way the assertion of Theorem 4.4 is proved.

Proving Theorem 4.4 we have just solved Problem A, which is equivalent to Problem 2. Thus, Problem 2 is solved, i.e., the coefficients of the optimal quadrature formula (1.1) in the sense of Sard in the space *K*_{2}*(P*_{3}*)* for equal spaced nodes are found.

### 5. The Norm of the Error Functional of the Optimal Quadrature Formula in the Sense of Sard

In this section we calculate square of the norm of the error functional (4.2) of the optimal quadrature formula (4.1).

The following result holds:

**Theorem ****5.1. **

The square of the norm of the error functional (1.2) of the optimal quadrature formula (1.1) on the space *K*_{2}*(P*_{3}*)* has the form

where

where are given in Theorem 4.1 and .

Proof. In the equal spaced case of the nodes, the expression (2.11), using (2.10), we can rewrite in the following form

where is defined by (4.3).

Hence taking into account equality (3.1) we get

Using equalities (4.2) and (4.3), after some simplifications, we obtain

(5.1) |

Now from (4.16) equating the corresponding coefficients of , and , for , and we get the following expressions

Substituting these expressions in (5.1) we find

where

Finally, using the expression for optimal coefficients from Theorem 4.4, after some calculations and simplifications, we get the assertion of Theorem 5.1. Theorem 5.1 is proved.

Now we give some numerical results.

For convenience the absolute value of the (1.5) of the optimal quadrature formula (1.1) we denote by . Then by the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality we have

(5.2) |

In the space using Theorems 4.4, 5.1 and (4.6), (5.2) for the error of the optimal quadrature formula (1.1) we have the results for the cases , 50 and 100 which are given in the second row of Table 1. In the third row of the Table 1 we give the results of the errors of optimal quadrature formula of the form (1.1) in the space which are given in the work ^{[24]}.

#### Table 1. Comparison the errors of optimal quadrature formulas in *K*_{2}*(P*_{2}*)* and *W*_{2}^{(3,2)} spaces for the cases *N = 10*, 50 and 100

The numerical results show that the errors of the optimal quadrature formula in the space is less than the errors of the optimal quadrature formula in the space for the cases and 50.

### 6. Conclusion

The paper is devoted to construction of the optimal quadrature formulas in the sense of Sard in the space . We found the extremal function which corresponds to the error functional and gave a representation of the norm of the error functional (1.2). The system of linear equations for the coefficients of the optimal quadrature formula is obtained. Moreover, we invastigated the existence and uniqueness of the solution of obtained system. Explicit formulas for coefficients of the optimal quadrature formula of the form (1.1) are found. The obtained optimal quadrature formula is exact for the functions , and . In Section 5 we calculate the norm of the error functional of the optimal quadrature formula and we give some numerical results.

### References

[1] | Ahlberg J.H., Nilson E.N., Walsh J.L. The Theory of Splines and Their Applications, Academic Press, New York - London (1967). | ||

In article | |||

[2] | Babuška I. Optimal quadrature formulas (Russian). Dokladi Akad. Nauk SSSR 149, 227-229 (1963). | ||

In article | |||

[3] | Blaga P., Coman Gh. Some problems on optimal quadrature. Stud. Univ. Babe S-Bolyai Math. 52, no. 4, 21-44 (2007). | ||

In article | |||

[4] | Boltaev A.K. On the extremal function of one optimal quadrature formula (Russian). Vopr. Vychisl. Prikl. Mat. -Tashkent, 125, 32-42 (2010). | ||

In article | |||

[5] | Boltaev A.K. Exictence and uniqueness of the solution of the system for optimal coefficients (Russian). Uzbek. Math. Zh. 2012, no. 2, 30-36. (2012) | ||

In article | |||

[6] | Bojanov B. Optimal quadrature formulas (Russian). Uspekhi Mat. Nauk 60, no. 6 (366), 33-52 (2005). | ||

In article | |||

[7] | Catina s T., Coman Gh. Optimal quadrature formulas based on the φ-function method. Stud. Univ. Babe S-Bolyai Math. 51, no. 1, 49-64 (2006). | ||

In article | |||

[8] | Chakhkiev M.A. Linear differential operators with real spectrum, and optimal quadrature formulas (Russian). Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR Ser. Mat. 48, no. 5, 1078-1108 (1984). | ||

In article | |||

[9] | Coman Gh. Quadrature formulas of Sard type (Romanian). Studia Univ. Babes-Bolyai Ser. Math.-Mech. 17, no. 2, 73-77 (1972). | ||

In article | |||

[10] | Coman Gh. Monosplines and optimal quadrature formulae in L_{P}. Rend. Mat. (6) 5, 567-577 (1972). | ||

In article | |||

[11] | Ghizzetti A., Ossicini A. Quadrature Formulae, Akademie Verlag, Berlin (1970). | ||

In article | CrossRef | ||

[12] | Hayotov A.R., Milovanovic G.V., Shadimetov Kh.M. On an optimal quadrature formula in the sense of Sard, Numerical Algorithm (2011) 57: 487-510. | ||

In article | CrossRef | ||

[13] | Köhler P. On the weights of Sard's quadrature formulas. Calcolo 25, 169-186 (1988). | ||

In article | CrossRef | ||

[14] | Lanzara F. On optimal quadrature formulae. J. Ineq. Appl. 5 (2000), 201-225. | ||

In article | |||

[15] | Maljukov A.A., Orlov I.I. Construction of coefficients of the best quadrature formula for the class W_{L2}^{(2)}(M;ON) with equally spaced nodes. Optimization methods and operations research, applied mathematics (Russian), pp. 174-177, 191. Akad. Nauk SSSR Sibirsk. Otdel. Sibirsk. Ènerget. Inst., Irkutsk (1976). | ||

In article | |||

[16] | Nikol'skii S.M. To question about estimation of approximation by quadrature formulas (Russian). Uspekhi Matem. Nauk, 5: 2 (36), 165-177 (1950). | ||

In article | |||

[17] | Nikol'skii S.M. Quadrature Formulas (Russian). Nauka, Moscow (1988). | ||

In article | |||

[18] | Meyers L.F., Sard A. Best approximate integration formulas. J. Math. Physics 29, 118-123 (1950). | ||

In article | |||

[19] | Sard A. Best approximate integration formulas; best approximation formulas. Amer. J. Math. 71, 80-91 (1949). | ||

In article | CrossRef | ||

[20] | Shadimetov Kh.M. Optimal quadrature formulas in L_{2}^{(m)}(Ω) and L_{2}^{(m)}(R^{1}) (Russian). Dokl. Akad. Nauk UzSSR 1983, no. 3, 5-8 (1983). | ||

In article | |||

[21] | Shadimetov Kh.M. Construction of weight optimal quadrature formulas in the space L_{2}^{(m)}(0,N) (Russian). Siberian J. Comput. Math. 5, no. 3, 275-293 (2002). | ||

In article | |||

[22] | Shadimetov Kh.M., Boltaev A.K. Construction of discrete analogue of the differential operator d^{6}/dx^{6}-1 and its properties (Russian). Uzbek. Math. Zh. 2011, no. 3, 209-216. (2011). | ||

In article | |||

[23] | Shadimetov Kh.M., Hayotov A.R. Optimal quadrature formulas with positive coefficients in L_{2}^{(m)}(0,1) space. J. Comput. Appl. Math. 235, 1114-1128 (2011). | ||

In article | CrossRef | ||

[24] | Shadimetov Kh.M., Hayotov A.R. Optimal quadrature formulas in the sense of Sard in W_{2}^{(m,m-1)} space. Calcolo, s 10092-013-0076-6 (2013). | ||

In article | |||

[25] | Shadimetov Kh.M., Hayotov A.R., Azamov S.S. Optimal quadrature formula in K_{2}(P_{2}) space. Applied Numerical Mathematics 62, 1893-1909 (2012) | ||

In article | CrossRef | ||

[26] | Shadimetov Kh.M., Hayotov A.R., Nuraliev F.A. On an optimal quadrature formula in Sobolev space L_{2}^{(m)}(0,1).J. Comput. Appl. Math. 243, 91-112 (2013). | ||

In article | CrossRef | ||

[27] | Schoenberg I.J. On monosplines of least deviation and best quadrature formulae. J. Soc. Indust. Appl. Math. Ser. B Numer. Anal. 2, 144-170 (1965). | ||

In article | |||

[28] | Schoenberg I.J. On monosplines of least square deviation and best quadrature formulae II. SIAM J. Numer. Anal. 3, 321-328 (1966). | ||

In article | CrossRef | ||

[29] | Schoenberg I.J., Silliman S.D. On semicardinal quadrature formulae. Math. Comp. 28, 483-497 (1974). | ||

In article | CrossRef | ||

[30] | Sobolev, S.L.: The coefficients of optimal quadrature formulas. Selected Works of S.L. Sobolev, pp. 561-566, Springer (2006). | ||

In article | CrossRef | ||

[31] | Sobolev S.L. Introduction to the Theory of Cubature Formulas (Russian). Nauka, Moscow (1974). | ||

In article | |||

[32] | Sobolev S.L., Vaskevich V.L.: The Theory of Cubature Formulas. Kluwer Academic Publishers Group, Dordrecht (1997). | ||

In article | CrossRef | ||

[33] | Vladimirov V.S. Generalized Functions in Mathematical Physics (Russian). Nauka, Moscow (1979). | ||

In article | |||

[34] | Zagirova F.Ya. On construction of optimal quadrature formulas with equal spaced nodes (Russian). Novosibirsk (1982), 28 p. (Preprint No. 25, Institute of Mathematics SD of AS of USSR). | ||

In article | |||

[35] | Zhamalov Z.Zh., Shadimetov Kh.M. About optimal quadrature formulas (Russian). Dokl. Akademii Nauk UzSSR 7, 3-5 (1980). | ||

In article | |||

[36] | Zhensikbaev A.A. Monosplines of minimal norm and the best quadrature formulas (Russian). Uspekhi Matem. Nauk. 36, 107-159 (1981). | ||

In article | |||

[37] | Shadimetov Kh.M., Hayotov A.R., Akhmedov D.M. Optimal Quadrature Formulas for the Cauchy Type Singular Integral in the Sobolev Space L_{2}^{(2)}(-1,1). American Journal of Numerical Analysis 1, no. 1 (2013): 22-31. | ||

In article | |||